Weekend reading links

1. The Economist points to the troubles facing Chinese manufacturing companies. The percentage of loss-making industrial enterprises is now even beyond the level of 1998 when reforms to the SOEs started.

At least eight large makers of the cars have shut down or halted production since the start of 2023. The ripples are visible throughout the supply chain... Some 52,000 ev-related companies shut down in China last year, an increase of almost 90% on the year before, according to one estimate. China’s solar industry is also grappling with oversupply. This year the prices of most components of solar modules have fallen below their average production cost. Many companies in the industry are scaling back manufacturing. Others have scrapped plans to enter the market... A shakeout is occurring in the semiconductor industry, too. Local governments have focused their investments on low-end chip components in an effort to “easily win market share”, notes an industry insider. Those parts are now in great oversupply and many of the companies producing them are failing. In 2023 nearly 11,000 chip-related firms went out of business, roughly 30 a day, according to Qichacha, a company that collects corporate data.

2. Nice graphic that captures China's latest investment priorities - solar, EV, batteries, and semiconductor chips.

3. Unintended consequences of public policy actions - in Germany, carbon emissions from power generation rose sharply in 2022 as it shut down nuclear plants.

4. You can do such market micro-management actions only if you are China

China has adopted an unusual tactic to discourage banks from buying government bonds, as authorities try to halt an uncomfortable decline in yields and prevent a bubble forming: naming and shaming the buyers... While buying of their sovereign bonds may be welcomed by many countries, the People’s Bank of China has repeatedly warned that a bubble is forming in the sovereign bond market, with regulators saying that regional banks’ appetite for long-term government debt risks triggering a Silicon Valley Bank-style crisis if there is a sudden surge in yields. “The local PBoC branch called us and advised us not to buy bonds when state lenders are selling,” one bond trader at a local lender in Jiangsu province said this week. “They blamed a few rural banks in Suzhou for acquiring bonds sold by the state banks.” On Monday, large banks sold a net Rmb22bn of long-dated bonds, 10 times the daily average last week, according to BNP Paribas’ securities market data. The government is also trying to spur economic growth by pushing regional lenders away from parking their money in ultra-safe bonds and instead lending it out.

5. Some facts about the trends in low tech manufacturing and China.

Apparel, footwear and furniture accounted for 9 per cent of China’s exports in the first eight months of last year, according to a Bank of America Global Research report, down from 20 per cent in 2001. Car and machinery’s share of total exports increased to 33 per cent from 16 per cent over the same period. China’s share of global footwear and apparel sales has slipped in recent years, with its portion of overall supply for brands Nike and Adidas falling from 20-27 per cent in 2017 to 16-20 per cent in 2022, according to the BofA report. While it remains the world’s largest supplier, China’s share of global footwear exports has declined by more than 10 percentage points over the past decade, according to figures from the 2023 World Footwear Yearbook. Much of that capacity has shifted to south-east Asian countries, particularly Indonesia and Vietnam, the report added. Vietnam, now the world’s second-biggest exporter, has been the biggest beneficiary, with its share rising from 2 per cent to about 10 per cent.

6. About the UK's Teacher's Pension Scheme (TPS)

State schoolteachers (and some university academic staff) are automatically enrolled into the Teachers’ Pension Scheme. The TPS requires contributions of at least 7.4 per cent of gross salary but guarantees an inflation-protected retirement income linked to career-average salary. Like most public-sector schemes it is unfunded; current pensions are paid out of current contributions and if they are insufficient then taxpayers are on the hook. It is also expensive for employers, who currently make contributions of about 28 per cent of salary.

7. Nice Ed Conway X thread on the challenges with replacing existing materials and technologies.

Part of the problem here - one which crops up again and again throughout *Material World* - is that it turns out the suite of materials we tend to use these days are simply VERY good at doing what they do. Kerosene is really hard to beat as an aviation fuel. Methane is a brilliant source of the hydrogen for making, among other things, fertilisers. Concrete might not be the only strong building material, but it’s incredibly easy to lay and also phenomenally cheap... All these things create significant carbon emissions. But they are central to modern life. They are a large part of the explanation for how we've been able to urbanise and feed billions of people in recent decades. Finding low carbon replacements will be HARD.

8. Two good Ed Conway X threads, here and here, on how countries got locked into the single pipe system where the outflows from sewerage and storm water drainage flows through one pipe (instead of separate pipes).

9. Very good graphical article in NYT that shows how China has established nearly 50 new villages and expanded another 100 villages all along its south-western borders, some in areas claimed by India and Bhutan, in an effort to fortify its border claims. 

These villages are called "border guardians" and the villagers are paid to live there. 

Qionglin’s villagers are essentially sentries on the front line of China’s claim to Arunachal Pradesh, India’s easternmost state, which Beijing insists is part of Chinese-ruled Tibet. Many villages like Qionglin have sprung up. In China’s west, they give its sovereignty a new, undeniable permanence along boundaries contested by India, Bhutan and Nepal. In its north, the settlements bolster security and promote trade with Central Asia. In the south, they guard against the flow of drugs and crime from Southeast Asia. The buildup is the clearest sign that Mr. Xi is using civilian settlements to quietly solidify China’s control in far-flung frontiers, just as he has with fishing militias and islands in the disputed South China Sea... The mapping reveals that China has put at least one village near every accessible Himalayan pass that borders India, as well as on most of the passes bordering Bhutan and Nepal... The outposts are civilian in nature, but they also provide China’s military with roads, access to the internet and power, should it want to move troops quickly to the border. 

Villagers serve as eyes and ears in remote areas, discouraging intruders or runaways... in quietly building militarized villages in disputed borderlands, China is replicating on land an expansionist approach that it has used successfully in the South China Sea... To persuade residents to move there, Chinese Communist Party officials promised them their new homes would be cheap. They would receive annual subsidies and get paid extra if they took part in border patrols. Chinese propaganda outlets said the government would provide jobs and help promote local businesses and tourism. The villages would come with paved roads, internet connections, schools and clinics.

10. Livemint reports of declining fortunes of Kota, the coaching centre capital of India - the number of students declined from around 200,000 in 2022 to and estimated 70000-90000 this year.  

The primary reason for Kota’s decline today is coaching institutes opening centres in other cities in the last two years, which has had a cascading effect on local businesses. Allen Career Institute, for instance, now has centres in at least 60 cities across India, including Dibrugarh, Patna, Rohtak, Latur, Jodhpur and Durgapur. Unacademy’s website says it has 61 centres in 44 cities for offline preparation, including Ahmedabad, Bhopal, Bhubaneswar, Bengaluru, Dehradun and New Delhi. Physics Wallah has 124 centres in 105 cities, with its Kota centre opening in 2022. It has more than 200,000 students enrolled across these centres... The other reason for the drop in students in Kota is the image it has developed of being a “suicide and party" hub. According to a Hindustan Times report last month, at least 13 students preparing for NEET or the engineering Joint Entrance Examination (JEE) in Kota had taken their own lives as of July. Last year, 27 suicides were reported, which was the highest number since 2015, said officials.

11. Very interesting snippet in the context of Bharti Airtel's decision to invest £3.2bn and take a 24.5% stake in BT, India is the second largest FDI source for UK!

India is the country’s second-largest source of foreign direct investment: there are more than 950 companies with combined revenue of about $65bn operating in Britain — up from 900 in 2022, according to the UK India Business Council... Bharti Enterprises holds controlling stakes in satellite venture OneWeb and also owns prestigious hotel brands, including The Hoxton and the Gleneagles resort in Scotland, operated by a company founded by his son-in-law. Bharti’s Africa telecoms business is a member of the FTSE 100.

And the Empire strikes back again?

On a 1997 visit to Bengaluru, then-UK prime minister John Major hailed BT’s acquisition of a 21 per cent stake in a phone operator owned by Sunil Bharti Mittal as “an indication of the strength of our economy”. Now Indian politicians are cheering a dramatic reversal after Mittal’s Bharti Enterprises struck a deal to become the British former telecoms monopoly’s largest investor, agreeing to buy a 24.5 per cent, roughly $4bn stake from Franco-Israeli billionaire Patrick Drahi’s indebted Altice. Bharti Airtel, anchor of the 66-year-old Mittal’s conglomerate, has blossomed since its 1995 founding into one of the world’s biggest network providers and now dwarfs BT. With 550mn customers across 17 South Asian and African nations, the company commands a $100bn market value — more than five times that of the UK group, which has shed overseas assets in recent years.

12. Water desalination facts of the day

Christopher Gasson, publisher of Global Water Intelligence, which tracks the industry, figures that about 500 million people rely at least partly on purified salt or brackish water and that the number could rise sixfold to three billion by midcentury. Around the world, there are about 1,500 large plants — those that can produce about 2.6 million gallons a day — with roughly $14 billion being spent annually to operate the existing fleet and build new ones... Saudi Arabia is the largest market for these installations, followed by the United Arab Emirates... With nearly 100 big plants, Spain is the largest user of desalination in Europe and one of the world’s largest... the costs of operating the energy-intensive desalination technology — called reverse osmosis, which is standard at large plants including the one at Torrevieja — are being brought down by pairing water purification with cheap solar energy, encouraging the building of new plants.

13. It appears that Howard Schulz negotiated out several perks for himself from Starbucks that raise concerns about corporate governance and personal ethics.

In 2018, the man who built the Seattle coffee business into a global empire had negotiated an agreement to retain an chair emeritus role — for the rest of his life. The deal lets the 71-year-old attend and observe board meetings, according to Starbucks corporate filings... They range from Starbucks reimbursing Schultz when it uses his private jet for corporate purposes to him owning a stake in a business making extra virgin olive oil for one of the company’s coffee drinks... The deal — which can only be modified or waived if both parties agree... As Schultz was ending his third spell in charge, he was introduced while travelling in Sicily to the idea of eating a spoonful of olive oil every day. It inspired him to create Oleato, which Starbucks began rolling out to customers earlier this year. Corporate filings show that Schultz did not just originate the idea; he also owned 19 per cent of the family-controlled business from which Starbucks buys its oil. Starbucks paid the company, Partanna, about $26mn last year... Schultz’s air travel also remains intertwined with the coffee chain. He owns a jet used by Starbucks, according to filings, for which the company last year paid an entity he controlled about $1mn. He has also stored his plane in a Starbucks hangar, the filings show: in 2023, an entity controlled by Schultz paid Starbucks about $1.3mn to cover rent and other maintenance costs.

For those who scorn at public servants for their questionable integrity, imagine what would have been the case if the likes of much-worshipped Schulz were in the public sector!

14. US CPI inflation falls to 2.9%. Time to call an end to the war on inflation?

15. An emerging structural concern in the banking sector in India is the widening gap between the credit and deposit growth rates. 

In the last financial year, for instance, while credit expanded at about 20 per cent, deposit growth lagged at about 14 per cent. The gap was also highlighted in the RBI’s latest Financial Stability Report. This trend is reflected in the credit-deposit ratio, which has increased since September 2021. It peaked at 78.8 per cent in December 2023 before moderating to 76.8 per cent at the end of March 2024. The ratio is particularly high among private-sector banks.

Some thoughts here. One, the high ratio among private banks is reflective of the problems with efficiency maximisation pursuit of the private sector, and the need for regulation to bring in resilience to the banking system. Two, as the editorial alludes to, the sharp decline in household savings to a multi-decade low of 5.3% of GDP in 2022-23 may be a reason behind the lower deposit growth rate (apart from the emergence of alternative savings opportunities). Three, just as savers find alternative investment opportunities, the borrowers must also diversify away from banks to capital market avenues. 

16. Interesting snippets of Chinese trade data

While China’s share of US imports has slipped to 13.5 per cent today from 21.6 per cent in December 2017, its overall market share in global goods exports has risen from 12.8 to 14.4 per cent over the same period.

17. Tim Harford on luxury brands

The real trick that luxury brands have pulled off is that the two features of the brand — subtle excellence paired with conspicuous expense — reinforce each other. In its purest form, conspicuous consumption is crass and unattractive; it needs the cover story of excellence before it becomes appealing. Both excellence and expense are part of the brand promise, then, but the difference between them matters. If the brand is mostly about excellence, the purchaser of the fake is the obvious loser: they are getting shoddy goods masquerading as something much better. But if high-end brands are largely about expense for the sake of expense, then counterfeit brands are like counterfeit banknotes. Their ubiquity debauches the value of the once-exclusive brand and the suckers are not the people who buy the fakes, but the people who pay retail for the tarnished originals...

But is this inability to signal quality really a problem for luxury fashion brands? I doubt it. Those who walk into the Louis Vuitton shop down the street from Florence’s Duomo and pay €500 for a baseball cap will be confident that they are getting the real thing, and rightly so. Those who pay €12 in a Palermo street market are expecting a knock-off, and they are right too... The economist Karen Croxson, now at the Competition and Markets Authority, once published a theory of “promotional piracy”, in which companies would tolerate the copying of some products because it created demand for the real thing. Microsoft probably benefits if tens of millions of schoolkids familiarise themselves with pirated copies of PowerPoint and Excel. And while the possibility of counterfeit Gucci loafers seems unlikely to enhance the appeal of the real thing, maybe some brands might be happy to see influential young artists, musicians and trendsetters displaying their logos, fake or not. Or maybe the ubiquity of the imitations builds demand for the original? Over in the Uffizi, “The Birth of Venus” is so prized because it is so recognisable, and that is down to it having been duplicated, imitated and remixed so often. Perhaps this is as true for Versace as it is for Botticelli.