Move on Prozac and depression, here comes Lyrica and fibromyalgia! This is the latest attempt by the big pharamceutical companies to first create and then capture the market in combating the new category of diseases - lifestyle diseases. The latest in the line of man made, life-style diseases is fibromyalgia, which apparently affects middle-aged women and is characterized by chronic, widespread pain of unknown origin. Pfizer has betted on a drug Lyrica, which has recently become the first US FDA approved drug for treating fibromyalgia, which is expected to follow Prozac and become the newest blockbuster drug. Other drug companies have also jumped the fray, with Eli Lilly and Forest Laboratories, asking the FDA to let them market drugs for fibromyalgia.
However, there is a furious debate raging about the disease itself. The supporters hope that Lyrica will legitimize fibromyalgia, just as Prozac brought depression into the mainstream. But opponents say that the disease does not exist and is only a physical response to stress, depression, and economic and social anxiety. They do not consider fibromyalgia a medically recognizable illness and say that diagnosing the condition actually worsens suffering by causing patients to obsess over aches that other people simply tolerate. They fear that Lyrica will be taken by millions of people who do not need them.
Substack
Wednesday, January 16, 2008
Tuesday, January 15, 2008
Empirical Analysis in anti-malaria activities
I am an ardent advocate of applying the Freakonomics methods in analysing public issues and in policy making. This post is a very strong live example of the utility of statistical analysis in governance. In one of my earliest posts, I had outlined how the Vijayawada Municipal Corporation (VMC) had initiated an anti-malaria drive in the city by utilizing certain simple techniques of statistical analysis. Without focussing on the details of how the success was achieved, I will merely flag off the utility of data analysis in addressing the malaria incidence.
Briefly, Vijayawada city is highly malaria endemic, and there used to be 5000 to 6000 positive cases detected in the City every year. The Malaria circle in VMC was divided into 53 sections which were serviced with equal intensity (or lack of it) by the Malaria Wing. But a close scrutiny of the Malaria trends in the 53 sections over a five year period, revealed certain startling conclusions.
It was found that a major proportion of the positive cases came from 10 sections. Within these 10 sections too, colony and street wise analysis was done to localize the prevalence. It was therefore decided in 2006 to give specific focus to anti-malaria activities in these 10 sections. A range of activities were initiated in these areas to address the problem. The next year, following the success of the experiment in these 10 sections, it was decided to give similar focus for the next vulnerable 12 sections.
Spurred by the success of these methods, which were first initiated in September 2005, a major Malaria Free Vijayawada 2011 campaign was launched in August 2007. The objective was to focus the application of these successful methods to cover the entire city and eradicate Malaria from Vijayawada. As a result, in addition to the original 22, another 8 vulnerable sections have been identified for intensified anti-malaria activities. These 30 sections constitute more than 90% of the positive cases in the 53 sections of the City.
The results have been nothing short of spectacular. While the number of positive cases detected were 6271 in 2005, it fell 53.4% to 2921 in 2006, and 40.15% to 1748 in 2007. In the 10 most endemic sections where these methods were initiated in mid-2005, it fell 54.4% from 2652 in 2005 to 1129 in 2006, and 28.6% to 805 in 2007. In the 12 next vulnerable sections where the campaign was initiated in January 2007, it fell 34.4% from 752 to 493. During the tree years, the blood smear collection samples too increased.
All this was achieved at reduced cost, compared to the previous years. The focus of anti-malaria activities was shifted to anti-larval and other preventive activities. Hitherto anti-malaria activites focussed heavily on Malathion fogging, which despite being found to be both ineffective and harmful to public health, continues to be the predominant focus in many areas. There are strong vested interests in ensuring its continuation, given the relatively higher costs of such activities. Malathion consumption fell from 9580 litres in 2005 to just 299.5 l in 2007. In contrast, reflecting the increased focus on anti-larval activities, the consumption of chemicals like Baytex, Pyrethrum, and Abate increased.
The aforementioned example is a simple illustration of the efficacy of data analysis in solving local problems. This approach can be an invaluable tool in identifying and then tackling many local problems and deficiencies in health and education sectors, especially given the wealth of information available with the respective departments.
Briefly, Vijayawada city is highly malaria endemic, and there used to be 5000 to 6000 positive cases detected in the City every year. The Malaria circle in VMC was divided into 53 sections which were serviced with equal intensity (or lack of it) by the Malaria Wing. But a close scrutiny of the Malaria trends in the 53 sections over a five year period, revealed certain startling conclusions.
It was found that a major proportion of the positive cases came from 10 sections. Within these 10 sections too, colony and street wise analysis was done to localize the prevalence. It was therefore decided in 2006 to give specific focus to anti-malaria activities in these 10 sections. A range of activities were initiated in these areas to address the problem. The next year, following the success of the experiment in these 10 sections, it was decided to give similar focus for the next vulnerable 12 sections.
Spurred by the success of these methods, which were first initiated in September 2005, a major Malaria Free Vijayawada 2011 campaign was launched in August 2007. The objective was to focus the application of these successful methods to cover the entire city and eradicate Malaria from Vijayawada. As a result, in addition to the original 22, another 8 vulnerable sections have been identified for intensified anti-malaria activities. These 30 sections constitute more than 90% of the positive cases in the 53 sections of the City.
The results have been nothing short of spectacular. While the number of positive cases detected were 6271 in 2005, it fell 53.4% to 2921 in 2006, and 40.15% to 1748 in 2007. In the 10 most endemic sections where these methods were initiated in mid-2005, it fell 54.4% from 2652 in 2005 to 1129 in 2006, and 28.6% to 805 in 2007. In the 12 next vulnerable sections where the campaign was initiated in January 2007, it fell 34.4% from 752 to 493. During the tree years, the blood smear collection samples too increased.
All this was achieved at reduced cost, compared to the previous years. The focus of anti-malaria activities was shifted to anti-larval and other preventive activities. Hitherto anti-malaria activites focussed heavily on Malathion fogging, which despite being found to be both ineffective and harmful to public health, continues to be the predominant focus in many areas. There are strong vested interests in ensuring its continuation, given the relatively higher costs of such activities. Malathion consumption fell from 9580 litres in 2005 to just 299.5 l in 2007. In contrast, reflecting the increased focus on anti-larval activities, the consumption of chemicals like Baytex, Pyrethrum, and Abate increased.
The aforementioned example is a simple illustration of the efficacy of data analysis in solving local problems. This approach can be an invaluable tool in identifying and then tackling many local problems and deficiencies in health and education sectors, especially given the wealth of information available with the respective departments.
Thursday, January 10, 2008
A recession in the rent seeking economy
It is not hyperbole to suggest that the corruption economy is the largest and most widely pervading sectors of the Indian (or any developing country) economy. With everybody talking of a recession in the US, I thought it an appropriate occasion for highlighing the situations under which the rent services economy goes to recession. What determines the price of rent seeking services? What are the distortions in the rent seeking market?
Unlike other sectors of the economy, the rent services sector has certain unique characterisitics. In fact, it would not be incorrect to even claim that the rent market has inherent monopoly characteristics. This is especially true of the more narrow market in the delivery of public services. The monopoly character is given by the fact that Government is the sole provider of such services, and the issuing official the sole authority designated with dispensing it. This makes it all the more vulnerable to price gouging.
Imagine this scenario. There is Department of Poverty Eradication, which is concerned with all the anti-poverty programs of the Government. It is led by a Minister and Heads of Department at the State level, and has tens of thousands of field functionaries, allocated across all the districts. Assume also that the major source of conventional rent seeking in this Department are from procurement and works, and from transfers of officials. The rent seeking chains are multiple and operate across many levels, and often leads upto the highest level. A typical rent chain works its way through different levels of the bureaucracy, bottom-up, (so rent seeking economy exhibits bottom-up characteristics!) and culminates at the decision making level. Given the inherent hierarchical nature of bureaucracy, this in turn means that the individual preferences of the particular decision making authority assumes great importance.
In such an arrangement, the price of the rent is invariably proportional to the rent charged by the highest link in the chain. In some ways this link becomes the price setter. If the highest link charges a high premium, there is a cascading effect across the entire length of the chain, thereby benefiting all the participants in the chain. But if the price charged is too high, there is the distinct possibility of pricing out potential customers. In contrast, if the highest link charges at a discount, it dampens the market and causes discontent among the participants. (Though not always true, generally the rents charged declines in value down the chain) In fact, there is a serious danger of the market itself drying up. Participants may find the price too low to compensate them for the risk undertaken, and may drop out, if only temporarily. In both scenarios, there is the potential for a recession in rent services. There are therefore inherent problems with both the rapacious and the more easily satifsied links.
But of the two scenarios, the former possibility is remote given the low price elasticity of demand for such services. This is especially true of the transfer market, where the depth and breadth, in terms of competing claimants, is often very small and the stakes too high. This ensures that the participation does not vary. Most participants in the rental market for transfers see the high rent values as something similar to making an investment in a high return capital asset, that keeps yielding handsome returns.
There are also situations where the rents have been hard wired into the architecture of the rent seeking economy - an economist would describe the rents as sticky - that it does not change with the official holding the postion. This is true especially at the lower levels of the bureaucracy, where the rents do not vary with changing officials. Such arrangements are likely to continue even if the cumulative rent price is higher than the price normally expected by the buyers. Recession also sets in when a more strict and incorruptible official assumes charge.
It often requires market intervention to stabilize the rent services market and take it out of recession. And this is precisely what actually happens. It is in the interest of the other participants in the chain, or the other stakeholders, to intervene and rectify the distortions. Interest groups soon develop to oust the rapacious or easily satisfied senior official, whose selfish actions have depressed the market and ushered in a recession. The same is true when there is an incorruptible official at the highest link. As is the case with all commodities and services traded in the economy, there is an equilibrium with rent services too, which is neither too high nor too low!
Unlike other sectors of the economy, the rent services sector has certain unique characterisitics. In fact, it would not be incorrect to even claim that the rent market has inherent monopoly characteristics. This is especially true of the more narrow market in the delivery of public services. The monopoly character is given by the fact that Government is the sole provider of such services, and the issuing official the sole authority designated with dispensing it. This makes it all the more vulnerable to price gouging.
Imagine this scenario. There is Department of Poverty Eradication, which is concerned with all the anti-poverty programs of the Government. It is led by a Minister and Heads of Department at the State level, and has tens of thousands of field functionaries, allocated across all the districts. Assume also that the major source of conventional rent seeking in this Department are from procurement and works, and from transfers of officials. The rent seeking chains are multiple and operate across many levels, and often leads upto the highest level. A typical rent chain works its way through different levels of the bureaucracy, bottom-up, (so rent seeking economy exhibits bottom-up characteristics!) and culminates at the decision making level. Given the inherent hierarchical nature of bureaucracy, this in turn means that the individual preferences of the particular decision making authority assumes great importance.
In such an arrangement, the price of the rent is invariably proportional to the rent charged by the highest link in the chain. In some ways this link becomes the price setter. If the highest link charges a high premium, there is a cascading effect across the entire length of the chain, thereby benefiting all the participants in the chain. But if the price charged is too high, there is the distinct possibility of pricing out potential customers. In contrast, if the highest link charges at a discount, it dampens the market and causes discontent among the participants. (Though not always true, generally the rents charged declines in value down the chain) In fact, there is a serious danger of the market itself drying up. Participants may find the price too low to compensate them for the risk undertaken, and may drop out, if only temporarily. In both scenarios, there is the potential for a recession in rent services. There are therefore inherent problems with both the rapacious and the more easily satifsied links.
But of the two scenarios, the former possibility is remote given the low price elasticity of demand for such services. This is especially true of the transfer market, where the depth and breadth, in terms of competing claimants, is often very small and the stakes too high. This ensures that the participation does not vary. Most participants in the rental market for transfers see the high rent values as something similar to making an investment in a high return capital asset, that keeps yielding handsome returns.
There are also situations where the rents have been hard wired into the architecture of the rent seeking economy - an economist would describe the rents as sticky - that it does not change with the official holding the postion. This is true especially at the lower levels of the bureaucracy, where the rents do not vary with changing officials. Such arrangements are likely to continue even if the cumulative rent price is higher than the price normally expected by the buyers. Recession also sets in when a more strict and incorruptible official assumes charge.
It often requires market intervention to stabilize the rent services market and take it out of recession. And this is precisely what actually happens. It is in the interest of the other participants in the chain, or the other stakeholders, to intervene and rectify the distortions. Interest groups soon develop to oust the rapacious or easily satisfied senior official, whose selfish actions have depressed the market and ushered in a recession. The same is true when there is an incorruptible official at the highest link. As is the case with all commodities and services traded in the economy, there is an equilibrium with rent services too, which is neither too high nor too low!
Wednesday, January 9, 2008
Crime and violent films
Economists Gordon Dahl of the University of California, San Diego, and Stefano Della Vigna, of University of California, Berkeley, have presented a paper at the annual meeting of the American Economic Association, in which they have claimed that the proliferation of violent films have contributed towards making the streets safer by keeping violence prone individuals inside film theatres. This conclusion goes against conventional wisdom, which argues that the brutal and gory violence depicted in cinemas contribute towards making the society more aggressive, violent and crime prone.
The study claims, "We find that violent crime decreases on days with larger theater audiences for violent movies. The effect is partly due to voluntary incapacitation: between 6PM and 12AM, a one million increase in the audience for violent movies reduces violent crime by 1.1 to 1.3 percent. After exposure to the movie, between 12AM and 6AM, violent crime is reduced by an even larger percent. This finding is explained by the self-selection of violent individuals into violent movie attendance, leading to a substitution away from more volatile activities. In particular, movie attendance appears to reduce alcohol consumption. Like the laboratory experiments, we find indirect evidence that movie violence increases violent crime; however, this effect is dominated by the reduction in crime induced by a substitution away from more dangerous activities. Overall, our estimates suggest that in the short-run violent movies deter almost 1,000 assaults on an average weekend. While our design does not allow us to estimate long-run effects, we find no evidence of medium-run effects up to three weeks after initial exposure."
Using a decade of national crime reports, cinema ratings and movie audience data to examine what has happened to rates of violent crime during and immediately after violent films are shown, they say, "Instead of fueling up at bars and then roaming around looking for trouble, potential criminals pass the prime hours for mayhem eating popcorn and watching celluloid villains slay in their stead. You’re taking a lot of violent people off the streets and putting them inside movie theaters. In the short run, if you take away violent movies, you’re going to increase violent crime." Their analysis of the vast data revealed that “on days with a high audience for violent movies, violent crime is lower.” They also claim that over the last decade, the showing of violent films in the United States has decreased assaults by an average of about 1000 a weekend, or 52,000 a year.
Describing these findings as the latest in a series of such studies in the "Freakonomics era", the NYT says, "Practitioners of the dismal science are transcending traditional subjects like labor and markets, and are now crunching numbers to evaluate matters like cheating among sumo wrestlers or the effects of a crackdown on cocaine."
The study is an excellent illumination of the fact that "if you can incapacitate a large group of potentially violent people, that’s a good thing." However, there are a number of other issues that remain unaddressed. How does the violence in the movies influence or impact on the audience, especially those already prone to violence? Does it sow seeds of violent conduct in otherwise non-violent and law abiding youth? Do viewing these movies make potential violent youth or individuals more violent? Do they go out and vent out their impulse for self-realization by indulging in more violent crime than they would otherwise have done?
The study claims, "We find that violent crime decreases on days with larger theater audiences for violent movies. The effect is partly due to voluntary incapacitation: between 6PM and 12AM, a one million increase in the audience for violent movies reduces violent crime by 1.1 to 1.3 percent. After exposure to the movie, between 12AM and 6AM, violent crime is reduced by an even larger percent. This finding is explained by the self-selection of violent individuals into violent movie attendance, leading to a substitution away from more volatile activities. In particular, movie attendance appears to reduce alcohol consumption. Like the laboratory experiments, we find indirect evidence that movie violence increases violent crime; however, this effect is dominated by the reduction in crime induced by a substitution away from more dangerous activities. Overall, our estimates suggest that in the short-run violent movies deter almost 1,000 assaults on an average weekend. While our design does not allow us to estimate long-run effects, we find no evidence of medium-run effects up to three weeks after initial exposure."
Using a decade of national crime reports, cinema ratings and movie audience data to examine what has happened to rates of violent crime during and immediately after violent films are shown, they say, "Instead of fueling up at bars and then roaming around looking for trouble, potential criminals pass the prime hours for mayhem eating popcorn and watching celluloid villains slay in their stead. You’re taking a lot of violent people off the streets and putting them inside movie theaters. In the short run, if you take away violent movies, you’re going to increase violent crime." Their analysis of the vast data revealed that “on days with a high audience for violent movies, violent crime is lower.” They also claim that over the last decade, the showing of violent films in the United States has decreased assaults by an average of about 1000 a weekend, or 52,000 a year.
Describing these findings as the latest in a series of such studies in the "Freakonomics era", the NYT says, "Practitioners of the dismal science are transcending traditional subjects like labor and markets, and are now crunching numbers to evaluate matters like cheating among sumo wrestlers or the effects of a crackdown on cocaine."
The study is an excellent illumination of the fact that "if you can incapacitate a large group of potentially violent people, that’s a good thing." However, there are a number of other issues that remain unaddressed. How does the violence in the movies influence or impact on the audience, especially those already prone to violence? Does it sow seeds of violent conduct in otherwise non-violent and law abiding youth? Do viewing these movies make potential violent youth or individuals more violent? Do they go out and vent out their impulse for self-realization by indulging in more violent crime than they would otherwise have done?
Tuesday, January 8, 2008
Fibonacci ratios and the Sensex
The ET carries Sensex 2008 target estimates made using the Fibonacci ratios - 0.382, 0.618, 1.618, and 1. The estimations of the yearly closing target, done based on the difference between the lowest and highest monthly closes, multiplied by the Fibonachi ratios, and then added to the highest monthly closing of the previous year, revealed striking similarity with the actual performance for four years from 2004 to 2007. In fact, at least one among these Fibonacci ratios has given a target that is in a range of +/- 5% of the final realised value of the Sensex for the next year.The table below reveals the similarity

The graph below charts the highest-lowest monthly closing trends for the past four years.

With this method of technical analysis, the Sensex 2008 is estimated to be 23094.27, 24828.61, 27635.89 and 32177.51 respectively, for the four Fibonacci ratios. Let us revisit this post on 31, December 2008!

The graph below charts the highest-lowest monthly closing trends for the past four years.

With this method of technical analysis, the Sensex 2008 is estimated to be 23094.27, 24828.61, 27635.89 and 32177.51 respectively, for the four Fibonacci ratios. Let us revisit this post on 31, December 2008!
Monday, January 7, 2008
A case for easing monetary policy in India
In a meeting with all bank chiefs last week, the Finance Minister requested them to soften interest rates, so as to maintain the current growth rates. The economic conditions present an interesting picture. While oil prices continue to move upwards, the inflation trends are more benign. Central Banks have to exercise their monetary policy levers by keeping a balance between the two, at times competing, concerns - growth and inflation. There are opinions both in favor and against easing the monetary policy. I will list out a few reasons as to why monetary policy should be eased.
In early 2007, with inflation threatening to touch 7% and beyond, and the Government facing coalition uncertainty, RBI was facing a difficult situation. The rising inflation in the early part of the year, coupled with the surge in foreign investments, both FDI and FPI, resulting in rising forex reserves raised major concerns within both the RBI and the Government. The RBI responded with a series of monetary tightening measures. The repo rate (at which RBI lends to banks) rose to 7.75% in three instalments, starting October 2006, the CRR went up to 7.5% in the same number of instalments from April 2007. It also raised the limit set on the amount of money that could be removed from the system by short-term (reverse repo) and long term (market stabilization) borrowing.
This monetary tightening has yielded results in the last six months, as WPI inflation has been brought down below 4%. With inflationary concerns allayed, the time has certainly come for growth concerns to take over. This means the RBI should ease the monetary controls and encourage investment. It is the time for aggressively cutting rates.
Monetary policy decisions are increasingly dependent on the global macroeconomic picture. Monetary policy autonomy has diminished to the extent that Central Banks have to factor in the fundamentals and the expectations in the global economy, atleast in the major economies of the world. It is in this context that India may be standing at a favorable position in the global growth cycle.
The US and Europe are easing their monetary policy out of compulsions arising from the sub-prime mortgage related credit squeeze and the imminent dangers of a recession. In contrast, India can afford to loosen monetary policy from a position of strength. A loose monetary policy is critical for continuing the rise in investment rates, at 35% of GDP, which is essential for sustaining the high 9-10% growth rates. In an increasingly integrated global economy, any US recession and low interest rates presents a great opportunity for India to sustain high economic growth without inflationary pressures.
A hard landing in the US and recession elsewhere in the developed world, will cause a fall in global aggregate demand, which will adversely affect the export-led growth economies. The high degree of integration between US and the Asian economies will only exacerbate any consequences of recession in the former, thereby triggering off a global slowdown. This will in turn dampen global oil, energy, food, and other commodity prices, and force down inflationary trends and lower import costs. Though these external shocks will definitely have an impact on our economic growth, India is uniquely positioned among the major economies to ride out this tide. Its low trade dependence, forming 23.5% of GDP, as compared to 36.6% for China and 72% for the ASEAN countries, and a large and fast growing domestic economy, ensures that the Indian economy will continue to remain largely decoupled from rest of the world. Its growing domestic savings rate, at 34% of GDP, and robust financial markets will only increase its ability to withstand external shocks.
There are no dangers of a credit flight or out of control inflation for the foreseeable future. A balanced play of the Impossible Trinity, by way of stable exchange rates and a gradual easing of capital mobility controls, will ensure that we are able to maintain interest rate autonomy.
I will list out a few reasons as to why monetary policy should be eased.
1. Low interest rates are critical for sustaining the rapidly increasing investment rate. It stood at 35% of GDP for 2006-07. Apart from reducing the cost of capital, it will also contribute towards sustaining the bull run in the equity markets.
2. Indian economic growth is extremely interest rate sensitive, given the large number of small and medium businesses, who depend heavily on bank credit. Further, the limitations imposed on accessing external borrowings, also increases the dependence on local bank credit.
3. A recession in the US and elsewhere will reduce consumption demand and hence lower aggregate demand, which in turn is likely to put downward pressure on import prices. A fall in global aggregate demand, is likely to also depress energy, commodity and foodgrain prices, thereby further lowering inflationary pressures.
4. The WPI is already at a very low 3.65% for the first week of December, and declining. Given that CPI follows the WPI, with a lag, the CPI is also set to fall in the coming weeks. Inflationary pressures are therefore well under control.
5. With declining rates elsewhere, prompted by the credit crunch, higher rates in India will open up carry trade like arbitrage opportunities, which are not necessarily desirable.
6. In the event of a recession in the US causing drop in FII inflows into emerging markets, a loose monetary policy could help provide the internal thrust to sustain and stabilize the stock markets.
7. In contrast, in the event of a capital flight into emerging markets, the low interest rates will reduce the incentives for financial market distortions that could encourage undesirable, hot money inflows.
8. By making rupee investments less attractive compared to the other currencies, low interest rates will reduce capital inflows and thereby control the exchange rate appreciation of rupee.
9. A low rate will leave the RBI with enough flexibility to manoeuvre without compromising on growth concerns, when the economy starts overheating, as it will frequently do.
10. The prevailing high interest rate regime had crowded in the overwhelming share of domestic savings into bank deposits, and crowded out the development of alternate investment avenues in the financial markets. The result is that such investments, including the equity markets (only 7% of population invest in shares), lack from adequate depth and breadth. A low rate regime could provide the opportunity for development of such market.
11. A lower rate will ease the demand for External Commercial Borrowings, which crossed $30 bn in 2007. India has emerged as the largest issued of foreign currency convertible bonds (FCCBs) in Asia, outside of Japan. While ECBs are to be welcomed as a source of investment alternatives, an over reliance on them, especially on certain categories, can have harmful medium and long term implications. We only need to look back at the East Asian currency crisis of 1997.
12. The low interest rates will give a filip to consumption growth as hire purchase and home loan markets will go up. The importance of the consumption driven growth multiplier for the economy is enormous.
More fundamentally, for far too long, interest rates in India have remained higher than the global average. It was understandable given the developing and closed nature of our economy, and high inflation rates. But these high rates had introduced many distortions into the economy. Now with economy opening up, financial markets getting integrated with the global markets, capital mobility restrictions being slowly eased, inflation coming under control despite the galloping oil prices, and global interest rates being eased, it is natural that our monetary policy be eased at the slightest opportunity.
As it is our interest rates are high enough to make the cost of capital for our corporates higher than their global competitors. At this stage of our economic growth, when we are stabilizing the high growth trajectory, it is important that we use every opportunity to lower the cost of capital for our corporates. Besides the immediate advantages, it also expedite the painless convergence of our economy with the global financial markets and also provide the Central Banks with greater flexibility to manoeuvre in times of inflationary pressures, economic downturns and financial crisis.
In early 2007, with inflation threatening to touch 7% and beyond, and the Government facing coalition uncertainty, RBI was facing a difficult situation. The rising inflation in the early part of the year, coupled with the surge in foreign investments, both FDI and FPI, resulting in rising forex reserves raised major concerns within both the RBI and the Government. The RBI responded with a series of monetary tightening measures. The repo rate (at which RBI lends to banks) rose to 7.75% in three instalments, starting October 2006, the CRR went up to 7.5% in the same number of instalments from April 2007. It also raised the limit set on the amount of money that could be removed from the system by short-term (reverse repo) and long term (market stabilization) borrowing.
This monetary tightening has yielded results in the last six months, as WPI inflation has been brought down below 4%. With inflationary concerns allayed, the time has certainly come for growth concerns to take over. This means the RBI should ease the monetary controls and encourage investment. It is the time for aggressively cutting rates.
Monetary policy decisions are increasingly dependent on the global macroeconomic picture. Monetary policy autonomy has diminished to the extent that Central Banks have to factor in the fundamentals and the expectations in the global economy, atleast in the major economies of the world. It is in this context that India may be standing at a favorable position in the global growth cycle.
The US and Europe are easing their monetary policy out of compulsions arising from the sub-prime mortgage related credit squeeze and the imminent dangers of a recession. In contrast, India can afford to loosen monetary policy from a position of strength. A loose monetary policy is critical for continuing the rise in investment rates, at 35% of GDP, which is essential for sustaining the high 9-10% growth rates. In an increasingly integrated global economy, any US recession and low interest rates presents a great opportunity for India to sustain high economic growth without inflationary pressures.
A hard landing in the US and recession elsewhere in the developed world, will cause a fall in global aggregate demand, which will adversely affect the export-led growth economies. The high degree of integration between US and the Asian economies will only exacerbate any consequences of recession in the former, thereby triggering off a global slowdown. This will in turn dampen global oil, energy, food, and other commodity prices, and force down inflationary trends and lower import costs. Though these external shocks will definitely have an impact on our economic growth, India is uniquely positioned among the major economies to ride out this tide. Its low trade dependence, forming 23.5% of GDP, as compared to 36.6% for China and 72% for the ASEAN countries, and a large and fast growing domestic economy, ensures that the Indian economy will continue to remain largely decoupled from rest of the world. Its growing domestic savings rate, at 34% of GDP, and robust financial markets will only increase its ability to withstand external shocks.
There are no dangers of a credit flight or out of control inflation for the foreseeable future. A balanced play of the Impossible Trinity, by way of stable exchange rates and a gradual easing of capital mobility controls, will ensure that we are able to maintain interest rate autonomy.
I will list out a few reasons as to why monetary policy should be eased.
1. Low interest rates are critical for sustaining the rapidly increasing investment rate. It stood at 35% of GDP for 2006-07. Apart from reducing the cost of capital, it will also contribute towards sustaining the bull run in the equity markets.
2. Indian economic growth is extremely interest rate sensitive, given the large number of small and medium businesses, who depend heavily on bank credit. Further, the limitations imposed on accessing external borrowings, also increases the dependence on local bank credit.
3. A recession in the US and elsewhere will reduce consumption demand and hence lower aggregate demand, which in turn is likely to put downward pressure on import prices. A fall in global aggregate demand, is likely to also depress energy, commodity and foodgrain prices, thereby further lowering inflationary pressures.
4. The WPI is already at a very low 3.65% for the first week of December, and declining. Given that CPI follows the WPI, with a lag, the CPI is also set to fall in the coming weeks. Inflationary pressures are therefore well under control.
5. With declining rates elsewhere, prompted by the credit crunch, higher rates in India will open up carry trade like arbitrage opportunities, which are not necessarily desirable.
6. In the event of a recession in the US causing drop in FII inflows into emerging markets, a loose monetary policy could help provide the internal thrust to sustain and stabilize the stock markets.
7. In contrast, in the event of a capital flight into emerging markets, the low interest rates will reduce the incentives for financial market distortions that could encourage undesirable, hot money inflows.
8. By making rupee investments less attractive compared to the other currencies, low interest rates will reduce capital inflows and thereby control the exchange rate appreciation of rupee.
9. A low rate will leave the RBI with enough flexibility to manoeuvre without compromising on growth concerns, when the economy starts overheating, as it will frequently do.
10. The prevailing high interest rate regime had crowded in the overwhelming share of domestic savings into bank deposits, and crowded out the development of alternate investment avenues in the financial markets. The result is that such investments, including the equity markets (only 7% of population invest in shares), lack from adequate depth and breadth. A low rate regime could provide the opportunity for development of such market.
11. A lower rate will ease the demand for External Commercial Borrowings, which crossed $30 bn in 2007. India has emerged as the largest issued of foreign currency convertible bonds (FCCBs) in Asia, outside of Japan. While ECBs are to be welcomed as a source of investment alternatives, an over reliance on them, especially on certain categories, can have harmful medium and long term implications. We only need to look back at the East Asian currency crisis of 1997.
12. The low interest rates will give a filip to consumption growth as hire purchase and home loan markets will go up. The importance of the consumption driven growth multiplier for the economy is enormous.
More fundamentally, for far too long, interest rates in India have remained higher than the global average. It was understandable given the developing and closed nature of our economy, and high inflation rates. But these high rates had introduced many distortions into the economy. Now with economy opening up, financial markets getting integrated with the global markets, capital mobility restrictions being slowly eased, inflation coming under control despite the galloping oil prices, and global interest rates being eased, it is natural that our monetary policy be eased at the slightest opportunity.
As it is our interest rates are high enough to make the cost of capital for our corporates higher than their global competitors. At this stage of our economic growth, when we are stabilizing the high growth trajectory, it is important that we use every opportunity to lower the cost of capital for our corporates. Besides the immediate advantages, it also expedite the painless convergence of our economy with the global financial markets and also provide the Central Banks with greater flexibility to manoeuvre in times of inflationary pressures, economic downturns and financial crisis.
Saturday, January 5, 2008
Age of risk
It did take the genius of Donald Rumsfeld to wake us up to the fact that we are living in an age of "known unknowns and unknown unknowns"! Uncertainty and risk are today the primary concern for everyone - individuals, businesses, governments, and society itself. The sources of uncertainty have multiplied and encompass every dimension of life. The importance of risk management is underlined by the emergence and growing salience of an exclusive Chief Risk Officer (CRO) in major private companies.
Globalisation has thrown up in its wake numerous risks arising from outsourcing, free movement of labor and capital, reduction of tariffs and opening up of economies etc. Globalisation and the resultant integration of markets, has rendered individual national policies on many issues ineffective and considereably reduced national autonomy in economic policy making. As the benefits of globalisation becomes cornered by a handful few, the overwhelming majority of those left-out are beginning to make their voices heard, often violently so. Economic globalisation is leaving behind an ever widening inequality gap, both within and between nations. And democratically elected governments can fail to hear the voices of the losers only at their peril.
Thanks to globalization, capitalism, as we understand it, is facing a crisis of confidence. While the consumers and investors are prospering, the employees are facing uncertain times. The unprecedented choice available across all categories of consumer goods, and that too at unbelievably low prices, have led to consumers shopping away to glory. Similarly among investors, the diverse portfolio of investment opportunities and an equity market that seems to be moving in only one direction, barring a few blips, has generated a feel-good wealth effect. But citizens as employees are facing uncertain times, with massive lay-offs, proliferation of low paying temporary jobs, de-skilling and need for re-skilling, falling real wages, reduced and even no benefits, and diminishing job security.
The recent collapse of the sub-prime mortgage market, made us realize that the global financial system, far from diversifying and mitigating risk, had become ever more opaque and complex. The real impact of globalisation and its attendant risks are being felt in the global financial markets. The success of securitized lending over the past decade has seen impressive feats of financial engineering, seeking to diversify risk and increase liquidity. This has resulted in the emergence of a veritable cornucopia of financial instruments and market players. But the proliferation of such instruments, instead of reducing systemic risk, appears to have increased it in the global financial system.
As Paul Krugman wrote, "The innovations of recent years — the alphabet soup of CDO’s and SIV’s, RMBS and ABCP — were sold on false pretenses. They were promoted as ways to spread risk, making investment safer. What they did instead — aside from making their creators a lot of money, which they didn’t have to repay when it all went bust — was to spread confusion, luring investors into taking on more risk than they realized." Though risk is today omnipresent in our financial system, we are in no position to identify it and and worse still do not have any clue about mitigating it! As Goldman Sachs have showed, the only way to make money appears to be to locate a risk and then transfer it to unsuspecting investors, and there are plenty of them around, and make money when the bet succeeds.
Beyond the financial system lurk even more dangerous risks arising from the challenges posed to our environment. This affects not only us, but has repercussions on the future of our children and grandchildren, and beyond. As the developing world, led by China and India, march towards catching up with the developed West, the opening act of an environmental nightmare appears to be unfolding. Negative externalities, be it by way of pollution or over exploitation, is taking its toll on our environment.
The biggest challenge is posed by the ever increasing threat of global warming arising from carbon emissions with its consequent impact on climate change. If the entire planet emitted CO2 at the rate the US does today, global emissions would be almost five times greater. As As Martin Wolf recently pointed out in the Financial Times, if there are to be limits to emissions, then there may also be limits to growth. But any limits to growth will have serious political consequences with resource distributional dimensions, both within, and more dangerously, between nations.
The issue of climate change is intertwined with the challenge of development itself, and about how the world will look like if the currently impoverished five-sixth of humanity catches up with the remaining sixth. At a time when development itself is increasingly energy dependent, the biggest scare scenario is painted by the "peak oil" theories, pointing to a world of high oil and energy prices, even as energy resources become ever more scarce. The story is no different with other commodities, all of whom are experiencing their highest prices. In the last five years, prices of gold has gone up 150%, zinc 250%, uranium 750%, copper four times, and nickel three times.
The recent fashion with bio-fuels is taking its toll on global food security. The massive demand for corn and other biofuel producing crops has resulted in diversion of the fixed land resources away from foodgrains and also exploitation of virgin forest lands. Generous subsidies have produced internal distortions that have only exacerbated the trend. This in turn has led to steep rises in food grain prices, manifested by "pasta strikes" in Italy, "tortilla riots" in Mexico, "tomato boycott" in Argentina, to "onion crisis" in India. The Economist's food price index is now at its highest since its introduction in 1845. Food inflation is affecting the rich and more critically the poor across the globe, and is an important political issue everywhere.
The changing consumption patterns, with a shift towards meat, eggs, and dairy products have also contributed towards straining the food supply chain. Despite all the technological breakthroughs, agriculture continues to remain vulnerable to the vagaries of weather and other natural forces. The surging global demand for foodgrains has depleted global food reserves, and send food prices soaring to historic highs. The high costs of inputs like seeds, fertilizers and pesticides means that the high prices for agriculture commodities are not translating into higher profits for farmers.
Geo-political risks are intensifying in an alarming manner. After having prematurely proclaimed the "end of history", Francis Fukuyama must be surely looking for cover, as the events of the past decade has shown that change, and very violent and unpredicatable one at that, is running as strong as ever. To the volatile cocktail of strife in West Asia, sub-Saharan Africa, Iran-Iraq, Afghanistan, North Korea, and sub-national threats to nation-states across the world, has been added the more dangerous, uncertain, and faceless threat posed by terrorism. In fact, terrorism has fast replaced threats from neighbours and other countries as the primary security risk for many countries.
The spectacular emergence of China, and to a lesser extent India, has surely rocked the geo-political balance of power. Kremlin watching has been replaced with deciphering the signals from Beijing as the popular pastime for political commentators.
The triumph of democracy has proved elusive as the story has not followed the script written in Washington. The experiments with democracy in various parts of Asia, Eastern Europe and Africa, have not gone much beyond the holding of elections, and have even slipped back to retrograde authoritarianism. In its own backyard, America is facing a strong ideological rebellion from Hugo Chavez. The Chavez inspired Bolivarian Revolution has swept through Latin and South America, overthrowing US-backed, right-wing leaders and replacing them with indigenous and left leaning governments.
Unfortunately, even as all these risks mount, we seem to be not fully aware of the gravitas of the problems staring at us. We are still squabbling with each other, busy running each other down, thereby even failing to acknowledge the problem. Many of these are issues which need to be tackled now and immediately, failing which its costs are too high to be imagined. Nobel Laureate Prof Kenneth Arrow, has an insightful cost-benefit analysis of the climate change problem in the latest Project Syndicate column, The Case for Mitigating Greenhouse Gas Emissions.
Risks have been ubiquitous throughout life, but what makes the present day risks more dangerous are their global dimensions. Nation states have become powerless in combating these changes. These risks do not respect national boundaries. Be it, climate change, terrorism, increasing inequality, food security, economic globalisation - all these risks can be addressed only by collective action, by summoning the will of all the nations of the world, big and small. Successfully addressing them demands that the big and richer nations should take the lead. This is partly because a major share of the solution to these problems lies there and more importantly only these nations have the resources and the capability to take the important leadership role on any meaningful efforts to tackle these challenges. Unfortunately, as seen by the tame conclusion of the recent UN Climate Change Conference in Bali, this leadership seems to be as scarce as ever.
All these challenges are both inclusive and global, as Ulrich Beck calls it "cosmopolitics", and it is time all nations come to the table and start tackling them before it is too late.
Globalisation has thrown up in its wake numerous risks arising from outsourcing, free movement of labor and capital, reduction of tariffs and opening up of economies etc. Globalisation and the resultant integration of markets, has rendered individual national policies on many issues ineffective and considereably reduced national autonomy in economic policy making. As the benefits of globalisation becomes cornered by a handful few, the overwhelming majority of those left-out are beginning to make their voices heard, often violently so. Economic globalisation is leaving behind an ever widening inequality gap, both within and between nations. And democratically elected governments can fail to hear the voices of the losers only at their peril.
Thanks to globalization, capitalism, as we understand it, is facing a crisis of confidence. While the consumers and investors are prospering, the employees are facing uncertain times. The unprecedented choice available across all categories of consumer goods, and that too at unbelievably low prices, have led to consumers shopping away to glory. Similarly among investors, the diverse portfolio of investment opportunities and an equity market that seems to be moving in only one direction, barring a few blips, has generated a feel-good wealth effect. But citizens as employees are facing uncertain times, with massive lay-offs, proliferation of low paying temporary jobs, de-skilling and need for re-skilling, falling real wages, reduced and even no benefits, and diminishing job security.
The recent collapse of the sub-prime mortgage market, made us realize that the global financial system, far from diversifying and mitigating risk, had become ever more opaque and complex. The real impact of globalisation and its attendant risks are being felt in the global financial markets. The success of securitized lending over the past decade has seen impressive feats of financial engineering, seeking to diversify risk and increase liquidity. This has resulted in the emergence of a veritable cornucopia of financial instruments and market players. But the proliferation of such instruments, instead of reducing systemic risk, appears to have increased it in the global financial system.
As Paul Krugman wrote, "The innovations of recent years — the alphabet soup of CDO’s and SIV’s, RMBS and ABCP — were sold on false pretenses. They were promoted as ways to spread risk, making investment safer. What they did instead — aside from making their creators a lot of money, which they didn’t have to repay when it all went bust — was to spread confusion, luring investors into taking on more risk than they realized." Though risk is today omnipresent in our financial system, we are in no position to identify it and and worse still do not have any clue about mitigating it! As Goldman Sachs have showed, the only way to make money appears to be to locate a risk and then transfer it to unsuspecting investors, and there are plenty of them around, and make money when the bet succeeds.
Beyond the financial system lurk even more dangerous risks arising from the challenges posed to our environment. This affects not only us, but has repercussions on the future of our children and grandchildren, and beyond. As the developing world, led by China and India, march towards catching up with the developed West, the opening act of an environmental nightmare appears to be unfolding. Negative externalities, be it by way of pollution or over exploitation, is taking its toll on our environment.
The biggest challenge is posed by the ever increasing threat of global warming arising from carbon emissions with its consequent impact on climate change. If the entire planet emitted CO2 at the rate the US does today, global emissions would be almost five times greater. As As Martin Wolf recently pointed out in the Financial Times, if there are to be limits to emissions, then there may also be limits to growth. But any limits to growth will have serious political consequences with resource distributional dimensions, both within, and more dangerously, between nations.
The issue of climate change is intertwined with the challenge of development itself, and about how the world will look like if the currently impoverished five-sixth of humanity catches up with the remaining sixth. At a time when development itself is increasingly energy dependent, the biggest scare scenario is painted by the "peak oil" theories, pointing to a world of high oil and energy prices, even as energy resources become ever more scarce. The story is no different with other commodities, all of whom are experiencing their highest prices. In the last five years, prices of gold has gone up 150%, zinc 250%, uranium 750%, copper four times, and nickel three times.
The recent fashion with bio-fuels is taking its toll on global food security. The massive demand for corn and other biofuel producing crops has resulted in diversion of the fixed land resources away from foodgrains and also exploitation of virgin forest lands. Generous subsidies have produced internal distortions that have only exacerbated the trend. This in turn has led to steep rises in food grain prices, manifested by "pasta strikes" in Italy, "tortilla riots" in Mexico, "tomato boycott" in Argentina, to "onion crisis" in India. The Economist's food price index is now at its highest since its introduction in 1845. Food inflation is affecting the rich and more critically the poor across the globe, and is an important political issue everywhere.
The changing consumption patterns, with a shift towards meat, eggs, and dairy products have also contributed towards straining the food supply chain. Despite all the technological breakthroughs, agriculture continues to remain vulnerable to the vagaries of weather and other natural forces. The surging global demand for foodgrains has depleted global food reserves, and send food prices soaring to historic highs. The high costs of inputs like seeds, fertilizers and pesticides means that the high prices for agriculture commodities are not translating into higher profits for farmers.
Geo-political risks are intensifying in an alarming manner. After having prematurely proclaimed the "end of history", Francis Fukuyama must be surely looking for cover, as the events of the past decade has shown that change, and very violent and unpredicatable one at that, is running as strong as ever. To the volatile cocktail of strife in West Asia, sub-Saharan Africa, Iran-Iraq, Afghanistan, North Korea, and sub-national threats to nation-states across the world, has been added the more dangerous, uncertain, and faceless threat posed by terrorism. In fact, terrorism has fast replaced threats from neighbours and other countries as the primary security risk for many countries.
The spectacular emergence of China, and to a lesser extent India, has surely rocked the geo-political balance of power. Kremlin watching has been replaced with deciphering the signals from Beijing as the popular pastime for political commentators.
The triumph of democracy has proved elusive as the story has not followed the script written in Washington. The experiments with democracy in various parts of Asia, Eastern Europe and Africa, have not gone much beyond the holding of elections, and have even slipped back to retrograde authoritarianism. In its own backyard, America is facing a strong ideological rebellion from Hugo Chavez. The Chavez inspired Bolivarian Revolution has swept through Latin and South America, overthrowing US-backed, right-wing leaders and replacing them with indigenous and left leaning governments.
Unfortunately, even as all these risks mount, we seem to be not fully aware of the gravitas of the problems staring at us. We are still squabbling with each other, busy running each other down, thereby even failing to acknowledge the problem. Many of these are issues which need to be tackled now and immediately, failing which its costs are too high to be imagined. Nobel Laureate Prof Kenneth Arrow, has an insightful cost-benefit analysis of the climate change problem in the latest Project Syndicate column, The Case for Mitigating Greenhouse Gas Emissions.
Risks have been ubiquitous throughout life, but what makes the present day risks more dangerous are their global dimensions. Nation states have become powerless in combating these changes. These risks do not respect national boundaries. Be it, climate change, terrorism, increasing inequality, food security, economic globalisation - all these risks can be addressed only by collective action, by summoning the will of all the nations of the world, big and small. Successfully addressing them demands that the big and richer nations should take the lead. This is partly because a major share of the solution to these problems lies there and more importantly only these nations have the resources and the capability to take the important leadership role on any meaningful efforts to tackle these challenges. Unfortunately, as seen by the tame conclusion of the recent UN Climate Change Conference in Bali, this leadership seems to be as scarce as ever.
All these challenges are both inclusive and global, as Ulrich Beck calls it "cosmopolitics", and it is time all nations come to the table and start tackling them before it is too late.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)