Tuesday, July 1, 2008

Survey on corruption in India

NGOs Transparency International India (TII) and Centre for Media Studies (CMS) have brought out the "India Corruption Study 2007", which finds that about one-third of Below Poverty Line (BPL) households in the country bribed officials to avail a total of 11 services — from police to PDS. The survey covering 22,728 households in all states and Union Territories, estimates that Rs 883 Cr was paid as bribe by BPL households last year.

A closer reading of the statistics throws up some very interesting pointers.

1. Perception of corruption is much higher than the actual experience, atleast for the most basic services. This indicates that the time may have come to revise the stereotype of rampantly corrupt public service delivery, though perceptions about corruption still remains. The fact that basic civic services like school education, PDS, health, and electricity appear to be relatively less corrupt only strengthens this arguement. The most heartening finding is that despite 54% of repsondents perceiving PDS as corrupt, only 8% experienced corruption (88% of repsondents accessed the PDS). The emergence of multiple corruption watchdogs, more pro-active approach to addressing corruption by Government agencies, and the general increase in public awareness due to greater economic and social empowerment may have been the contributing factors for this heartening development.

Interestingly, though NREGS is perceived by 47% as corrupt, only 11% experienced corrupt practices, and only 7.5% actually paid bribes. But unlike other services, the local non-officials formed a quarter of the bribe recipients. The relatively lower level of corruption in NREGS may once again be attributed to many of the aforementioned factors.

2. That police, land records, and housing are the three most corrupt services is understandable given the huge stakes involved. In the case of Police, not only are the stakes very high but there is also an element of urgency involved, both of which gets cashed in by rent seekers. The financial stakes are very high in case of housing and land records. That a significant number of respondents used a contact to access these three service also underlines their importance. Interestingly, despite the fact that these three are the least used services, they make up more than 50% of the total bribes paid. Further, unlike other services, corrupt staff and not procedural or other issues are the main problems faced by the citizens in accessing these services.

3. That only a very small percentage (less than 5%) of those refused to pay a bribe when faced with a need to do so, indicates a citizenry which has accepted bribes as a part of reality.

4. The survey shows a surprisingly low level of involvement of political representatives in corrupt practices in delivery of public services. Again, contrary to widely held perceptions, the role of middlemen has been declining and officials collect bribes directly. That citizens now deal directly with officials, dispensing with intermediaries, is in itself an encouraging development.

The major concern from the findings of the study is the amount of corruption involved in the delivery of police, land records and housing services. These three services, which are used by only 10-15% of population are not percived to be the most corrupt, but also are the most corrupt. Unlike other common public services, which have become more impersonal and more readily exposed to public scrutiny, these three involve closer interaction with officials, thereby opening up greater probability of corrupt practices.

It is therefore important that the public watchdogs, Government, and anti-corruption agencies focus attention on these three departments. We may need to, like banking sevices which are found relatively less corrupt, introduce technological innovations like more computerization to make processes more transparent and functionaries accountable in these departments. We also need to make the delivery of these services more impersonal by eliminating the need for multiple interactions with officials.

It is ironical that the departments administered directly by the three All India Services officers - IAS, IPS and IFS (land records, police, and forest) are the three most corrupt departments!

3 comments:

Realty Rider said...

Booming markets invariably bring with it unsavory people, who try to make some quick money through dubious methods. This is more or less the state of India’s property market at this point of time. There are developers who sell the same piece of land to number of customers and there are those who sell land without clear titles or mandatory permissions from the authorities.
There are many fly-by-night operators and others in the unorganized sector who indulges in such fraud. So what should a buyer do? I would suggest buyers to investigate the background of any developer thoroughly. Believe me, if you are not careful, your life’s savings could be at risk.For more view- realtydigest.blogspot.com

ASHISH said...

hii sir..i m an aspirant of civil services,,,i wondered on the ideas u have written on this blog...wud u plz guide me in that how u developed them...by reading or by thinking.....?
i wish2 make my economix strong...most frequently i find appreciation,inflation,FDI,volatility,US housing sector crisis...all these n i dont get any general import of the words....sir ur words wud be guiding bible4me...if you plz reply on books of economix2b studied4 civil services mains.....of course besides ur subliminal blog content...my mail id is "ashish.drdo@gmail.com"...plz reply sir...plz plz plz

parimal said...

want to change some thing or need to comeover corruption in country, visit Jaago Re Campaign for Change, find talented social workers, create a group and do what you want.

Who says doing social good is all work and no play? Here is a fun contest to get you started on contributing to LIVE NGO projects!

Jaagore.com brings you ‘Campaign for Change’ - an online contest for all those who have the innate desire to do participate in social change and contribute to making a better society. The contest is currently live on Jaago Re Campaign from Tata Tea and is an ideal platform for each of us to contribute to the Jaago Re! mantra of Social Awakening!

There are only two simple parts to the contest:
a. Create a poster or a video or both along with a slogan( based on your choice of an NGO project) & upload the entry
b. Publicize your entry by getting your friends to ‘Volunteer’ for the NGO project

The two best entries with the maximum Volunteers and Jury Points win a cash prize + Jaago Re! Campaign for Change certificates!

This contest is one of unique ways through which Jaagore.com is trying to spread awareness on social issues and publicize NGO projects that need volunteer support. So, show your support by participating now!

Click on campaign-for-change | Jaagore

Do share the link with all your friends and post the contest URL on all your social network profiles on Facebook & Twitter to spread the word about this contest!