Weekend reading links

1. Europe too has its chokepoints over China and the US.

A group of experts called the Geostrategic Europe Taskforce last week published a report which “identifies 41 critical chokepoints where China depends on the EU for more than 80 per cent of its imports, and 67 such dependencies for the United States. These span essential inputs including insulin, pharmaceutical intermediates, medical technologies, and specialised machinery for agriculture, paper production, and industrial processing.” And the German economic think-tank Dezernat Zukunft has also just released a study highlighting that “Europe has more cards than it thinks. We control 80 per cent of US uranium imports. Siemens dominates the turbines US data centres desperately need.”

2. US and Western VCs are struggling to exit their China investments.

Ten of the biggest buyout firms with investments in China including KKR, Blackstone and CVC had zero publicly disclosed complete divestments from mainland Chinese portfolio companies in 2025, according to data from providers PitchBook and Dealogic.

3. Declining attention spans.

A 2022 survey by King’s College London found that 49 per cent of UK adults feel their attention span is shorter than it used to be. Forty-seven per cent feel “deep thinking” has become a thing of the past. Studies that monitor people’s attention in their real-world environment show that since 2004, the average time people stay focused on a single task has dropped from about 2.5 minutes to roughly 47 seconds, according to data tracked in Attention Span, a book by Gloria Mark, professor of informatics at the University of California, Irvine.

4. South Korean stock markets rose 76% last year to become the best-performing major market. 

Retail investors have bought a net Won6.3tn ($4.3bn) of locally listed stocks since the start of 2026, according to Korea Exchange, the country’s securities market operator. In addition, they have pumped Won13tn into Korean ETFs, helping boost the benchmark Kospi by 35 per cent this year and making it one of the world’s best-performing stock market indices for the second year running... The number of individual active stock trading accounts in Korea topped 100mn for the first time last month — the equivalent of roughly two accounts for every member of the population. Deposits held at retail brokerages, reserved for stock purchases, hit a record Won103tn this month, up from Won87tn at the end of last year. Margin balances (the funds investors have borrowed from brokerages to buy stocks) have also surged to a record at Won31.5tn.

5. The MAGA right and progressive left converge in their opposition to emerging AI trends.

AI opposition spans the political spectrum. Democrat Senators Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren warn against corporate power concentration and job displacement, while Maga strategist Steve Bannon and Republican Senator Josh Hawley spread warnings about the dangers of empowering tech billionaires... The list of grievances being raised against AI is varied. At the local level, communities are fighting the construction of data centres that they worry will disrupt resources such as water, land and electricity... Meanwhile, in Hollywood, celebrities have launched the “Stealing Isn’t Innovation” campaign against the use of creative work for AI training, and parents, along with 37 state attorneys-general, are pressing for accountability after Grok, xAI’s chatbot, facilitated the generation of non-consensual nude images of women and children.

6. China announces restrictions on exports of rare earth magnets and other critical minerals, in the guide of "dual-use materials", to dozens of Japanese companies, especially vehicle makers.

7. Contrary to Elon Musk's claims that space-based data centres are three years away, they may be decades away.

Google’s satellite-based data centre initiative, Project Suncatcher, estimates that launch costs would need to fall below $200 per kilogramme (a sevenfold reduction from current levels) before this becomes economically viable. That threshold isn’t expected until the mid-2030s. Even if costs do fall, the components required — including radiation-hardened servers, on-orbit communications infrastructure and in-space servicing capabilities — do not yet exist at commercial scale. Adding to the conundrum, orbital data centres turn routine IT management into a complex space systems problem. On Earth, a failed server can be replaced in minutes. In orbit, that task requires either sophisticated in-space servicing or acceptance of degrading performance and stranded capital that becomes orbital debris as components age and fail. Burning satellites up when they become obsolete is not environmentally neutral: the process injects metal particles into the upper atmosphere where they can affect winds, temperatures and ozone chemistry.

8. On the importance of manufacturing for national economic development.

Most successful development stories — from Britain’s Industrial Revolution to South Korea’s transformation to China’s ascent — have run through the factory floor. Manufacturing drives productivity through economies of scale that services struggle to replicate. It generates innovation spillovers that ripple through entire economies. It enables countries to access global markets at a scale services cannot match. And contrary to fears about automation eliminating manufacturing jobs, countries like China demonstrate that manufacturing can absorb hundreds of millions of workers even as robots proliferate... Digital platforms, financial services, and business process outsourcing... cannot replace manufacturing’s role as the engine of sustained productivity growth and structural transformation...

Between 1750 and 1950, the West’s establishment as the world’s economic hegemon was fundamentally a process of becoming the world’s manufacturing hegemon. Since 1950, this pattern has persisted with remarkable consistency. A World Bank study published in 2008 identified 13 countries that sustained annual growth rates of 7% or higher for a period of 25 years or longer. Among these growth miracles, only two — Botswana and Oman, both small countries with highly idiosyncratic economic structures — achieved this without manufacturing-led development... recent data by the UN Industrial Development Organisation (UNIDO) arrive at similar conclusions. In their Industrial Development Report 2026, they highlight that 64% of growth episodes over the last 50 years can be directly attributed to manufacturing... Manufacturing firms spend heavily on research and development (R&D), generating strong innovation spillovers throughout the economy. In fact, manufacturing is attributed to 53% of global R&D activity. Manufacturing provides the material foundation for innovation, creates demand for new technologies, and enables the accumulation of productive capabilities that underpin further innovation.

9. Britain has a peculiar worsening trend in graduate fortunes. 

10. Good illustration of how regulations may be stifling European business environment. From Pieter Garciano

The whole point of the AI Act, is to create an extremely consistent and level playing field across all of Europe to allow like companies to face a much larger market straight away. The problem is that because of directives, the actual enforcement of a given law is left to the member state and the member states are ordered to create their own regulatory bodies. So for example, in the case of the AI Act, every single member state is ordered to have a notifying authority and an enforcement authority... these different regulators, they talk to each other, but they’re not necessarily forced to agree with each other... And so you have cases where the Irish regulations happened with GDPR, the Irish Data Protection Authority said to Meta, this is excellent. You can do X or Y. And then the Austrian and German data protection authorities disagreed and then fine Meta billions of euros. And so, this is a case where the law, even if you agree with the intent of the law, the way it’s currently being executed, which is through directives, makes it so that you’re going to always get an extremely high friction and fragmented regulatory system... They currently have, I think the count is between these four laws, they’ve created 270 different tech regulators... And that of course has really distortionary effects as well for what kind of basically very large fixed cost. And so if you’re a large company, if you’re a Google or a Meta, you have a thousand guys in your Brussels compliance office and they’re really good at this. But if you’re a smaller company, then you actually really struggle with figuring out what the 270 different bodies want you to do.

European regulators have been influenced by beliefs against big corporations and their market power, which explains both their anti-trust actions against Big Tech and refusal to approve European mergers like those between Siemens and Alstom.  

11. China is leading the race for humanoid robots, including those which resemble human beings and mimic their facial expressions while talking. This is a real advance.

Galbot’s silvery humanoid folds T-shirts, retrieves a bottle of water from a shelf and rolls walnuts about in its hands. Developing multifunctional hands has been a major challenge for robot makers, requiring advanced sensitivity and a high density of mechanical components. The Beijing-based company says its robots can be used for household tasks or in retail contexts such as shops and pharmacies... Galbot, backed by Chinese battery giant CATL, also showed its humanoid picking up irregular shards of broken glass, suggesting “integration of perception, grasp planning, and controlled force and precision, differentiating the performance from purely staged movement”, according to analysts at Morgan Stanley.

12. Is the National Green Tribunal (NGT), the primary appellate authority against orders of the Ministries of Environment of state and central governments, becoming a captive of ease of doing business?

Between 2020 and 2025, of the 329 appeals filed by citizens and activists against the grant of clearances by the Government, only in 20% (65 cases), did the NGT rule in favour of the appeal. Conversely, when the project’s proponents appealed against the denial of clearances by the government, in nearly 80% (126 of 160) of the cases, they secured relief. This is not a historical norm. Data from 2016-2019 shows a more balanced era where relief for both sides hovered between 18% and 31%. This pro-project trend has accelerated sharply in the last 24 months. Between 2024 and 2025, only 7% of appeals challenging clearances were successful. In contrast, 88% of industry-led appeals against clearance rejections got relief... of the 264 unsuccessful citizen appeals during 2020–2025, a significant portion was dismissed on technical grounds, labelled “time-barred” for more than 90 days delay in filing. The rest were dismissed as “not tenable,” or lacking “any merit.”

13. Excellent article by Richard Hurowitz on how gum arabic, a sap that comes from the acacia tree, is fuelling the civil war in Sudan, joining Sierra Leone's blood diamonds and DRC's cobalt in fuelling their respective civil wars. 

Found in everything from soft drinks and candy to cosmetics and pharmaceuticals, gum arabic is a critical ingredient for Coke and Pepsi and gives an M&M its distinctive shell. Commonly listed as E414 on labels, it’s an ingredient in pet food, chewing gum, lipstick, pill capsules and throat lozenges... the groves of Sudan’s subsistence farmers produce 70-80 per cent of the global supply. And no one has yet found an effective synthetic substitute. Sudan exported some 60,000 tonnes of its “white gold” in the year prior to the conflict. It is no surprise, then, that multinationals have been stockpiling gum arabic since the civil war started... 

It is also, tragically, being used to finance what the UN has declared the world’s worst humanitarian disaster. Since April 2023, Sudan has been engulfed in a civil war between the government in Khartoum’s Sudanese Armed Forces and the rebel Rapid Support Forces. The war has drawn in foreign powers including Saudi Arabia, the UAE, Turkey, Russia and Egypt... The crisis in Sudan dwarfs any other current conflict on every measure... According to a former US envoy, over 400,000 people have died. More than 15mn have been displaced. Tens of thousands of Sudanese have been massacred, there is widespread sexual violence and a man-made famine has sent millions into starvation... Both sides have used the commodity to finance their efforts... and the SAF continues to export what it can while the RSF smuggles its supplies abroad... The RSF controls large portions of the main gum-producing regions in Darfur and Kordofan where they have looted warehouses, seized shipments and imposed fees on harvesters and traders. Tens of millions of dollars’ worth of gum arabic has been stolen, smuggled and sold to finance their military operations. At the same time, the SAF controls Port Sudan, where taxes on gum arabic exports fill its coffers with revenue.

14. The killing of Nemesio Oseguera, the leader of Mexico's Jalisco New Generation Cartel (CJNG) has once again drawn attention to Mexico’s pervasive drug gang problem.

Weekend reading links

1. Blackstone is Spain's biggest residential property landlord. 

Over the past decade, Blackstone has become Madrid’s largest private owner of residential real estate, and the second largest in all of Spain. Ms. Riquelme’s apartment is one of 13,000 that Blackstone currently owns in Madrid, and among 19,600 it owns nationwide. Across Spain, around 185,000 rental properties are now owned by large corporations, half of those by firms based in the United States, according to a review of property registries by the nonprofit Civio. Rental prices have increased 57 percent since 2015 and home prices 47 percent, according to PwC, in large part because the country has failed to build enough homes for its growing population, even as more than 4 million homes sit empty. After the pandemic pushed Spain’s unemployment rate up to 15 percent, evictions nationwide spiked. In Madrid, tenant groups estimate that 20,000 renters in the city currently face the threat of eviction.

Ms. Riquelme, a bookkeeper by trade, emigrated from Chile in 2000 and bought her apartment for 56,000 euros during the housing bubble, making mortgage payments to CaixaCatalunya, a now defunct bank. After she and her husband split, she could no longer keep up, and the bank eventually foreclosed. CaixaCatalunya sought €150,000 ($170,000) in fees and mortgage arrears, then sold her apartment at auction for just €40,000 ($45,000) to a subsidiary of Blackstone... Ms. Riquelme’s apartment was one of 400,000 private units across the country bought a decade ago by three American equity firms: Blackstone, Cerberus and Lone Star. Blackstone oversees at least 27 different domestic subsidiaries and investment funds in Spain that use a variety of models to buy both private and public housing. Some funds have focused on buying foreclosed residences, often converting entire buildings into short-term rentals. Others have scooped up public-housing units from cash-strapped city governments and then privatized them. Still more bought up homes as the government cleared its books of troubled assets after nationalizing several banks amid the Eurozone debt crisis...

For Blackstone, it was an expansion of a real estate plan that took root in the wake of the 2008 housing crash... In 2013, Madrid’s city government sold 5,000 public-housing units to Blackstone and to another American investment bank, Goldman Sachs. Blackstone bought 1,860 apartments in 18 complexes for €128.5 million ($146 million) — including hundreds of units in the PAU development in Carabanchel. That amounts to just €69,500 (about $78,000) per unit, on average. A court-mandated audit of the deal later revealed that the sales were made at well below market rates... These days, just 2 percent of Spanish homes available for rent are public housing, according to the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development. In France it’s 14 percent; in the Netherlands it’s 34 percent.

2. The Chairman of Maruti Suzuki India Ltd (MSIL), the largest car maker in India, has said that car purchases in India are largely limited to the top 12% of households with an annual income of over Rs 12 lakh. MSIL reported a 4.3% year-on-year decline in net profit for Q4 FY 25. While overall passenger sales for 2024-25 grew by 2% to 4.3 million units, the sale of small cars declined by 9%. He said, 

“We have seen that in this current year, the sale of small cars (sedans and hatchbacks) has declined by about 9 per cent. So, if there is a 9 per cent decline in the car segment that is bought by 88 per cent of the people in this country, from where will you get the growth?” he added. Bhargava further noted that India has penetration of cars of just 34 of 1,000, “probably the lowest among any country around this area of the world”. “For a country that is growing, this PV sales growth rate of just 2-3 per cent a year is not going to increase the penetration of cars at all... especially because 2025-26... growth has been foreseen at 1-2 per cent.” The MSIL chairman expressed doubts on whether the major income tax relief, given by the Union government in the latest Budget, is going to boost small car sales in 2025-26.

“The cost of the car has gone up by an average of ₹80,000-90,000. How much cash will the income tax relief give? People are not going to put all the income tax savings aside and use it to buy a car. They have other priorities too. I mean, these are small households and they have many requirements. Their children have requirements. A car is not going to be the top requirement for these people,” he said. The small car segment has been declining over the past few years. In 2024-25, the Indian car industry sold 1.353 million sedans and hatchbacks, which was about 12.6 per cent lower year-on-year, according to Siam. Bhargava said it is a fallacy to think that the decline in the small car market and the growth of the SUV (sport utility vehicle) market is a result of people’s aspirations changing, and people wanting to buy big cars. “It's not true. What is happening is that people can’t afford small cars,” he added.

3. Is there a bond market "put" that's a boundary for President Trump's policies?

Nouriel Roubini, the economist, telling his clients that “traders [now] trump Trump”. Or, to put it another way, there now seems to be a bond market “put”, or a level of price swings that will force the White House to modify policy, at least verbally — probably around 4.5 per cent for 10-year yields.

4. The world of Trump in a graphic!

Adam Posen says

“China at present imports very few things from the US that it can’t get from others, including money. The US imports all kinds of things that we can’t get from anyone other than China at speed, or at affordable prices.”

Wonder why he does not ask where China will sell all its $300 bn odd goods that used to go to the US, and how those factories will remain open?

5. Robots are largely born in Asia. 

6. Important illustration of public engagement with scientific research promotion.

In June 1941, and in response to a proposal by the MIT engineer Vannevar Bush, Roosevelt established the Office of Scientific Research and Development. Bush was its head, reporting directly to the president. The results of its work — mass production of penicillin for battlefield wounded, proximity fuses that transformed anti-aircraft fire, and, not least, the Manhattan Project — made an unarguable case for the partnership between government and university-based research science... Largely forgotten now beyond histories of science, he was one of the 20th century’s most remarkable visionaries, not least for his conviction that peacetime federal governments had an obligation to fund basic scientific research, liberated from the demands of commercial profit...

Bush argued that since colleges were “the wellsprings of knowledge and understanding”, they should be parties to research contracts with the government that would provide the necessary stability of funding for sustained experimental work. This would guarantee the “free play of free intellects working on subjects of their own choice, in the manner dictated by their curiosity for exploration of the unknown”. The National Science Foundation, created by Congress and signed into law by President Harry S Truman in May 1950, owed much to Bush’s eloquence and vision.

7. The US Treasuries have not been a risk-free asset for several decades, as this graphic's volatility shows. 

This is a good long read on the US Treasury basis trades of hedge funds.  

8. Vietnam's problems in two graphics. China's share of its imports doubled to 32% between 2005-22. 

And in the same period, US share of its exports rose from 18% to 29.5%!

Vietnam's merchandise trade (imports plus exports) as a share of its GDP rose from 96% in 2000 to 158% in 2023!

9. Manufacturing trends

But most economists agree that the decline in manufacturing jobs is mainly the result of rising productivity. New technologies have boosted output per worker, pushing down the relative price of manufactured goods. One study by Michael Hicks and Srikant Devaraj at Ball State University in Indiana estimated that 88% of the decline in manufacturing jobs in America between 2000 and 2010 can be attributed to productivity improvements. Trade accounted for only 13%.

Changing consumption patterns are also a factor. When incomes rise in poor countries, individuals tend to spend less on food and more on manufactured goods, a phenomenon known as Engel’s law. When incomes rise in rich countries, consumption shifts away from manufactured goods towards services. In 1950 goods accounted for around 60% of American consumption; today they represent just a third of spending with services accounting for two-thirds.

10. Some statistics on India's life and health insurance markets. 

Health and general insurance companies covered 572 million lives in FY24. The industry settled claims worth Rs 83,500 crore in FY24, up 17.7 per cent from FY23. It processed 26.8 million claims that year, up from 23.5 million the previous year, and 21.8 million in FY22. The stand-alone health insurance companies improved their claim ratio to 89 per cent in FY24, from 84 per cent in FY23. The industry had an agent network of 1.9 million and assets under management of Rs 4.75 trillion in FY24. There were 25 general insurance companies in FY24, including four public sector undertakings. The number of stand-alone health insurance companies was five. Overall, the non-life insurance penetration in India, which includes health insurance, is just 1 per cent of GDP. This includes health coverage by different government schemes. Globally, the US has the maximum non-life insurance penetration (9.3 per cent), followed by the Netherlands (7.2 per cent), Canada (4.7 per cent), Germany (3.4 per cent), and Australia (3.3 per cent). Insurance penetration is measured as the percentage of insurance premium to gross domestic product (GDP)... 

Medical inflation was 14 per cent in FY24, the highest in Asia... the growth rate in health insurance dropped in FY25 to 8.98 per cent from 20.25 per cent in the previous year, with the gross premium income of insurers at Rs 1.18 trillion against Rs 1.08 trillion in FY24... The stand-alone health insurance industry operated on around a 3.5 per cent profit margin in 2023-24 (FY24). For the overall general insurance industry, it’s slightly higher. The private general insurers enjoy a much higher margin; the public sector players much lower. The average margin for hospitals could be at least 30 per cent.

11. Signs of re-routing of Chinese manufactured exports to the US.

Some China-based firms hit hard by US tariffs are reaching out to Indian exporters to fill orders on their behalf and help them retain their American customers as they navigate a trade war causing seismic shocks in global commerce. At the Canton Fair that runs through May 5 in Guangzhou — the world’s biggest trade fair — several Indian firms were approached by Chinese companies to supply goods to their US customers... In return for the sales, the Indian firms would pay a commission to the Chinese businesses... Indian firms at the Canton Fair were instead approached to supply goods to US companies under the brands of the Chinese firms, or co-branded with the Indian firms... Most of the queries came in sectors like hand tools, electronics and home appliances... The commission paid to the Chinese firms would be negotiated between the buyers and suppliers.

12. India healthcare facts of the day.

India’s out-of-pocket expenditure (OOPE), as a percentage of total health expenditure (THE), declined from 62.6 per cent in 2014-15 to 48.2 per cent in 2018-19, the year when Ayushman Bharat was launched. Since then, it has dropped down further to 39.4 per cent in 2021-22. Such reduction in OOPE has gone hand-in-hand with increased public spending in healthcare from 29 per cent of THE in 2014-15 to 48 per cent in 2021-22.

Over half of those admitted in the Ayushman Bharat authorised hospitals for treatment under the scheme were above 45 years.

90% of the 36,118 empanelled hospitals have less than 50 beds. 

13. Good article that brings out the issues likely in the India-US FTA negotiations. Important point that the value add in India on an iPhone retailing for $1000 is less than $25, compared to $450 captured by the US. 

14. FT graphics on 100 days of Trump. 

Market reactions and electoral support will likely be the two restraining forces on Trump. His pause on reciprocal tariffs in reaction to the Treasury market convulsions is definitive evidence. The stock market performance in the first 100 days of Trump has been the worst in five decades!

15. World trade facts of the day

Between 1995 and 2023, world trade (goods and commercial services) registered strong growth, averaging 5.8 per cent per year, resulting in almost a fivefold increase... (it) outpaced growth in global gross domestic product (GDP), which increased by an average of 4.4 per cent per year over the same period. The global trade-to-GDP ratio showed a significant upward trend, rising from 20 per cent in 1995 to 31 per cent in 2022.

16. Finally, the collapse of the Spanish and Portuguese electricity grids is a stark reminder of the challenges with electricity grid management once intermittent renewables assume a high share of the energy mix.  

At 12.33pm local time on Monday, the frequency on Spain’s electricity grid suddenly dropped, from the 50 hertz level at which the grid’s operator tries to maintain it, to 49 hertz, according to Aurora Energy Research, a consultancy. A move bigger than 0.1 hertz forces many power stations to automatically switch off for safety reasons. Any loss of power in Spain has an immediate knock-on effect in Portugal, which relies heavily on its neighbour for electricity supplies... Frequency fluctuations are not uncommon, but grid operators normally overcome them by asking power generators to increase or decrease their output, or by using batteries. However, in this case, not enough additional generation capacity could be brought online fast enough...

Renewables are weather-dependent, but solar panels lack the big turbines that can help keep the system running if there is a power failure somewhere along the line — a process known as “inertia”. About a fifth of Spain’s annual electricity supply comes from solar, on average, but at lunchtime on Monday the proportion was far higher — at more than 55 per cent. Aurora said the lack of inertia “contributed to the instability”... Greater use of batteries, as well as cables that import and export power to other countries, can also help balance out intermittent supplies. Spain’s relatively poor connection with France has long been a source of complaint in Madrid.

In fact, it's reported that of the scheduled 26 GW of electricity supply on Monday, just 5 GW came from non-intermittent sources.

Weekend reading links

1. Robin Harding writes that AI advances may not help much in the development of humanoid robots.

The obstacles to making an economically viable robot that can cook dinner and clean the toilets are a matter of hardware, not just software, and AI does not in itself address, let alone resolve them. These physical challenges are many and difficult. For example, a human arm or leg is moved by muscles, whereas a robotic limb must be actuated by motors. Each axis of motion through which the limb must move requires more motors. All of this is doable, as the robotic arms in factories demonstrate, but the high-performance motors, gears and transmissions involved create bulk, cost, power requirements and multiple components that can and will break down. After creating the desired motion, there is the challenge of sensing and feedback. If you pick up a piece of fruit, for example, then the human nerves in your hand will tell you how soft it feels and how hard you can afford to squeeze it. 

You can taste whether food is cooked and smell whether it is burning. None of those senses is easy to provide for a robot, and to the extent they are possible, they add more cost. Machine vision and AI may compensate, by observing whether the fruit is squashed or the food in the pan has gone the right colour, but they are an imperfect substitute. Then there is the issue of power. Any autonomous machine needs its own energy source. The robot arms in factories are plugged into the mains. They cannot move around. A humanoid robot is most likely to use a battery, but then there are trade-offs with bulk, power, strength, flexibility, operating time, usable life and cost. These are just some of the problems.

2. Nvidia does not seem to agree as it bets on robotocs as its next big growth driver. 

Nvidia... is set to launch its latest generation of compact computers for humanoid robots — dubbed Jetson Thor — in the first half of 2025. Nvidia is positioning itself to be the leading platform for what the tech group believes is an imminent robotics revolution. The company sells a “full stack” solution, from the layers of software for training AI-powered robots to the chips that go into them... The push into robotics comes as Nvidia is experiencing more competition for its powerful AI chips from rival chipmakers such as AMD, as well as cloud computing groups such as Amazon, Microsoft and Google that are looking to reduce their dependence on the US semiconductor group... a shift in the robotics market is being driven by two technological breakthroughs: the explosion of generative AI models and the ability to train robots on these foundational models using simulated environments. The latter has been a particularly significant development as it helps solve what roboticists call the “Sim-to-Real gap”, ensuring robots trained in virtual environments can operate effectively in the real world, he said... Nvidia offers tools at three stages of robotics development: software for training foundational models, which comes from Nvidia’s “DGX” system; simulations of real-world environments in its “Omniverse” platform; and the hardware to go inside the robots as its “brain”.

3. Pakistan drastically reduces pension benefits of retired civil and armed forces personnel to reduce its growing pension bill, the fourth largest expenditure in the budget. 

The Ministry of Finance on Wednesday issued three separate notifications to discontinue multiple pensions, reducing both the first home take pension and also lowering the base for determining future increases in pensions... According to the Ministry of Finance’s notification, on the recommendations of the Pay and Pension Commission of 2020, “it has been decided that henceforth, in an event where a person becomes entitled to more than one pension, such person shall only be authorised to opt to draw one of the pensions”... Instead of taking a pension on the basis of the last drawn salary, the new pensioner will get a pension based on the average salary of the last two years... It also ended the annual compounding of the pension and any increase would be treated separately from the base pension, a concept that is similar to the ad-hoc salary increase that is not made part of the basic salary to avoid compounding. The changes will take effect from January 1 and will be applicable to both retired civil and military personnel. Many serving federal government employees, who are taking salary and pension, would also be affected by the changes. The finance ministry’s notifications stated that the changes in the pension rules have been made on the basis of recommendations given by a commission constituted by the government of former prime minister Imran Khan in 2020.

4. A good description of how Chinese exporters are responding to US tariffs.

In industry after industry, Chinese companies have found footholds abroad that allow them to bypass trade barriers with the United States. After the United States put hefty tariffs on Chinese solar panels, for example, many Chinese companies opened solar factories in Southeast Asia... U.S. efforts to block critical minerals and electric vehicle batteries from China from receiving government subsidies have also pushed Chinese companies to set up battery-making subsidiaries in Morocco and Singapore... In some cases, global companies have also used accounting and tax tricks to make it appear that their shipments from China are lower, and thus pay fewer tariffs, without making major changes to their supply chains... For example, an electronics company might move one important stage of its supply chain out of China and into Vietnam. That could allow the company to report to U.S. customs agents that the export came from Vietnam, even if the good is still finished in China and exported from China to the United States. Another lever companies could play with, Ms. Brown said, is valuation. They can officially lower the value of the import by stripping out certain “intangible” costs, like payments for intellectual property, royalties, brand or research and development, and recording those to other global subsidiaries. By lowering the value of the import, they then pay a lower tariff.

5. Important point about the origins of uncertainty and risks in the global order today.

According to John Ikenberry of Princeton University, a leading theorist of international relations, “a revisionist state has arrived on the scene to contest the liberal international order . . . it is the United States... Trump is poised to contest almost every element of the liberal international order — trade, alliances, migration, multilateralism, solidarity between democracies, human rights”. As a result, rather than supporting the international status quo, the US is poised to become the leading disrupter. “Every talk I’ve ever given on the geopolitical risks that we face in the world started with China and Russia,” says Ivo Daalder of the Chicago Council on Global Affairs. “But the biggest risk is us. It’s America.” America’s traditional allies are among the countries that feel most threatened by a change in the way that the US exercises its power. Middle-power democracies such as the UK, Japan, Canada, South Korea, Germany and the entire EU have got used to a world in which American markets are open — and the US provides a security guarantee against threatening authoritarian powers... The question of whether and how to respond to Trump tariffs is exercising diplomatic minds across the western world. Finding an answer is all the more difficult because Trump’s true intentions remain unclear.

6. Interesting inequality trends

So we have seen no increase in aggregate inequality. The story for the lowest-paid is unambiguously good but for the bulk of people who sit somewhere in the middle, it could be argued that the two divergent trends combine for a decidedly uncomfortable situation. If the middle class looks upwards, the rich are pulling further away. A top-tier life feels further out of reach than ever. But look down, and the floor is coming up fast. This simultaneous rise of resentment and precarity is a dangerous cocktail, and could certainly have fed into recent political undercurrents.

Professions once considered aspirational are at the sharp end. In Britain, doctors, nurses and police officers have all been slipping down the income rankings in recent years. In the US, the highest-paying jobs are increasingly shared among a handful of ultra-high-status occupations. Tech workers now account for one in six of the top 5 per cent of salaries, up from one in 20 in 1990... In the 1980s, 40 per cent of the highest-paying jobs in America didn’t require a degree. The upper reaches of the income scale included plenty of engineers and doctors, but also senior schoolteachers and the most skilled factory and construction workers. People from all sorts of backgrounds with all sorts of skillsets could dream of making it. Today, the upper part of the scale is dominated by highly skilled tech and healthcare workers. Almost half of the top jobs require an advanced degree. And a huge section of the population knows at a pretty early age they’re not on that path.

7. Some numbers of household savings in India.

Net household financial savings in India rose from 7.7 per cent of gross domestic product (GDP) in 2019-20 to 11.7 per cent in 2020-21, largely because of precautionary and forced savings during the pandemic, but moderated thereafter to a multi-decade low of 5.3 per cent in 2022-23... The share of low-cost current and savings accounts in total deposits has declined the past few years from a peak of 44-45 per cent in recent years to 38-39 per cent. In contrast, mutual funds, especially equity and hybrid schemes, have seen a surge in inflows and have delivered higher returns over the past few years. The share of mutual funds constituted around 6.1 per cent of household savings in 2022-23, with the number of mutual-fund folios jumping from 146 million at the end of 2022-23 to 178 million at the end of 2023-24.

8. Finally, after years of wrangling including several lawsuits, congestion pricing in busy hours goes live in mid-town Manhattan from the morning of 6th January.

Most passenger cars will now have to pay $9 to enter Manhattan south of 60th Street at peak hours, rather than the original $15. Small trucks will have to pay $14.40; large trucks, $21.60. Discounted rates will be offered overnight when there is less traffic. M.T.A. leaders expect the new tolls to help generate $15 billion through bond financing that will pay for a long list of transit repairs and improvements, including modernizing subway signals and stations and expanding the electric bus fleet... State officials said the original plan was expected to reduce the number of vehicles in the congestion zone by roughly 17 percent. They have not specified how the scaled-back program will compare except to say they expect it to cut traffic by at least 10 percent... The tolling plan also does not directly charge drivers and owners of for-hire vehicles, which have exploded on city streets since Uber’s arrival in 2011. Instead, a small per-trip fee — $1.50 for Ubers and Lyfts; 75 cents for taxis — will be added to each fare and paid by passengers... Within the congestion zone, the average travel speed has dropped to under 7 miles an hour for the first time since records were kept in the 1970s, he said. The slowest traffic crawls along at just 4.7 miles per hour in Midtown.

See also this.  

9. As Saudi Arabia wins the bid for the 2034 Football World Cup, FT writes on the country's ongoing boom in infrastructure investments.

Saudi Arabia has launched real estate and infrastructure projects worth $1.3tn since Vision 2030 was unveiled in 2016, according to estimates by consultancy Knight Frank. These projects, such as the Neom linear smart city, include adding more than 362,000 hotel rooms and 7.4mn square metres in retail space. Football has become one of Prince Mohammed’s prime targets for sporting investment. The country’s sovereign wealth fund acquired English Premier League side Newcastle United, while superstars such as Ronaldo and Neymar have been lured to play in the Saudi Pro League. Saudi Arabia’s bid said the 48-team World Cup would be played in 15 stadiums across five cities. Eight stadiums would be in or close to Riyadh, which is already undergoing a construction boom that includes an entertainment zone to the west and a major expansion to the capital’s airport.

10. Adam Tooze points to a UNTD report that highlights the large differences in the cost of debt between Western countries and low-income ones.

11. Doing business, Huawei style.

Huawei’s first business was importing telephone switches before building its own, cheaper versions, copying foreign designs in the process. It later benefited from a government policy to rip out foreign technology in China’s communications network. Huawei developed a reputation for generosity towards government officials and telecoms executives, paying for international travel and hosting lavish banquets at its campus. Dou portrays Ren as an expert networker, including sending birthday cakes to retired telecoms experts who had helped Huawei.

12. Divisions in the Trump coalition that will only grow.

The Maga crowd and the globalists disagree not only on immigration, but on defence, employment and free speech. This is a coalition whose most significant overlap was a desire to take down the previous government. Now that they have, I think it’s unlikely they’ll come together on anything else.

13. Stunning figures about the US economy from Ruchir Sharma

Following the pandemic, government spending rose sharply as a share of GDP. More than 20 per cent of new US jobs are now created by government, up from 1 per cent in the 2010s. Public transfers including Social Security account for more than a quarter of residents’ income in more than 50 per cent of US counties — up from just 10 per cent in 2000.

14. Corporate India's acute deficit of global brands

Many Indian brands have either disappeared or ceded space to foreign competition. Where Onida and Videocon once dominated the domestic market for TVs, washing machines, and household appliances, Japanese, Korean, and, increasingly, Chinese brands now rule the showrooms. In cars, the Premier Padmini and Ambassador vanished when Japan’s Suzuki set up its joint venture to launch the Maruti, an Indian brand only in name. Here, too, it is the Japanese, Koreans, Germans, and Chinese that offer consumer choices, with Tata and Mahindra & Mahindra being the only indigenous exceptions. In fast-moving consumer goods, brands such as Anchor, Nirma, Uncle Chipps, and Binny’s, which once gave multinational players a run for their money, have all vanished or receded to the margins of the market... The abdication of Indian brands to global competition — with many of them converting themselves into contract manufacturers — reflects the lack of long-term thinking and strategic imagination, which are critical to brand-building.

15. This is what US Treasury Secretary-nominee Scott Bessent thinks.

Bessent has also suggested that countries with military protection from America should be forced to buy more dollar debt, as a quid pro quo. “Is there some kind of statecraft to do where you go to [these countries] and say we have these 40- or 50-year military bonds [to buy]?” he said, citing Japan, Nato members and Saudi Arabia.

16. Finally, Tej Parikh presents some facts about European stocks that go against conventional wisdom. Excluding Nvidia, European stocks outperform S&P 500 since the latest bull market started in October 2022!

European stocks are undervalued compared to their American peers.

Tech accounts for around just 8 per cent of the Stoxx Europe 600. AI euphoria has mostly passed the continent by... The Granolas... covers a diverse group of international companies spanning the pharmaceutical, consumer and health sectors. Together, they account for about one-fifth of the Stoxx 600. Their performance against the Magnificent Seven has only recently diverged. The S&P 500 — which has around 70 per cent revenue exposure to the US — got a jolt following the election of Donald Trump... Small listed European businesses also tend to outperform their American counterparts. About 40 per cent of US small caps have negative earnings, compared with just over 10 per cent in Europe. The winner-takes-all dynamic may be stronger in the US, where tech behemoths suck capital and talent away from smaller companies... European corporates also rely more on relationship-based, illiquid funding, unlike in the US, where listed equity dominates. That may encourage longer-term corporate governance in Europe... Regarding the Trump tariff threat, it’s not all disaster for European companies either. Stoxx 600 groups derive only 40 per cent of their revenues from the continent... A stronger dollar would also boost the earnings of European companies with sizeable US sales.

Weekend reading links

1. From a few months back, Andy Mukherjee peers ahead into the future of banking in the Indian context,

Google Pay wants to push time-deposit products of small Indian banks that don’t have much of a retail liability franchise of their own. According to a press release, Equitas Small Finance Bank will offer Google Pay customers up to 6.85% interest on one-year funds as part of a “branded commercial experience” on the platform... The move has global significance. It shows the tenuous nature of the hold financial institutions have on a core operation like deposit-taking, and their vulnerability to an assault from online search, social media and e-commerce behemoths. Alphabet, Facebook Inc. and Amazon.com Inc. may pose a far bigger challenge to brick-and-mortar lenders than fintech startups that don’t have the scale of platform businesses. Just like in India, deposit-strapped challenger banks might throw the keys to tech intermediaries with hundreds of millions of active users. When the giants storm the fortress, even larger banks will lose control of banking..

China’s homegrown tech titans have already shown how easy it is to dislodge traditional lenders from lending... India’s deposit-taking institutions don't have any special advantage left in moving retail money. Yes, they still hold the accounts for sending or receiving funds. But rather than transacting on their bank apps or cards, customers prefer to use Google Pay or Walmart Inc.’s PhonePe to pay one another and merchants... Since it won’t even take two minutes for a platform to book deposits from scratch, if another lender offers a better deal, idle funds might go there next. Customer loyalty, which is often just plain inertia, will no longer ensure stickiness... For a fee, platforms can easily extend their insights into consumer behavior and payment flows to influence deposit mobilization. The higher the commission, the lower the banks’ profit... Regulated institutions may be left holding a license to take deposits--and a thick rule book accompanying that privilege--but platforms will decide if a bank’s promotional offer is to be displayed prominently or buried in an obscure corner. The same slow, painful decline that gutted the print media after readers and advertisers moved online and publishers lost their sway over them may be waiting in the wings for banking, too.

2. FT has an interesting report on Dominic Cummings, former chief of staff to Boris Johnson and one of the leading forces behind his Brexit campaign. Cummings who courted numerous controversies during his tenure with Johnson at 10 Downing Street had a very bitter break-up with his boss, and is now leading a concerted campaign of leaks and media attacks to bring down Johnson.  

When he was at 10 Downing, Cummings, with his views on technocracy and scorn for the bureaucracy, had become a sort of poster child for tech-enthusiasts and supporters of bureaucratic reform. But as events since have shown, his hypocrisy and duplicity in trying to unseat Johnson reveals a dangerous and petty mind, one who is best kept as far away from the public realm as possible.

3. Business Standard reports on the near extinction of Indian mobile phone makers and the rise and rise of Chinese ones. 

To give a sense of the scale of opportunity, the Chinese makers sold over Rs 1.45 trillion worth mobile phones between January-October 2021. 

4. On the topic of Indians being successful outside India, there may be couple of statistical factors. One, Indians who emigrate are more likely to be the best and brightest, and therefore a super high quality pool with significant likelihood of spawning corporate leaders. Second, within the high quality pool of emigrants to the US, Indians are among the largest and naturally more likely to contribute such corporate leaders.

As I have written earlier, it's intriguing that all these highly successful Indians are concentrated as managers and executives, and there is hardly any presence in the ranks of similarly successful entrepreneurs. It does say something about the general nature of the emigrants. 

5. India's formal sector too may not be out of the woods,

Since the onset of the pandemic, the Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) has allowed members to avail of an advance to deal with expenses arising from Covid-19. Data from EPFO shows that between April 2020 to September 2021, 1.5 crore such claims were received. This implies that 23 per cent of India’s formal labour force (an upper limit, based on those contributing to EPFO) has availed of this facility. (Members were allowed to do so twice from June 2021). Of these 1.5 crore claims, 87.2 lakh were received in 2020-21. This works out to an average of 7.26 lakh claims per month. In comparison, in just the first six months of 2021-22 (April-September), 63.4 lakh such claims were received, at an average of 10.5 lakh per month. This suggests that not only has the formal labour force continued to face economic hardship, but also that it has been of a similar if not higher magnitude in the ongoing financial year.

It would be useful to compare these trends with the pre-pandemic share of EPFO members availing advances.  

6. Ganesan Karthikeyan has an interesting article where he argues that the endgame for Covid 19 has began. He claims that unlike till now, when the dominant mutants seek to maximise transmissibility, once large proportion of population are either immunised or infected the mutations that provide the virus with an evolutionary advantage are ones that help it evade immunity. Such mutants are more likely to produce milder illnesses so that its transmissibility is less reduced. 

He also makes an interesting point about what happens when the pandemic ends,

As has already become evident, we aren’t going to have lifelong protection after infection or vaccination. It is reasonable to expect that the virus will continue to mutate to evade immunity. Of the several unsavoury scenarios, one optimistic (and perhaps also likely) possibility is that the virus continues to circulate but infects only people without immunity — children born after the pandemic, older adults, or others with waning immunity. These vulnerable individuals will continue to require vaccination. This is presumably what happened after the 1918 pandemic. That virus now causes seasonal influenza.

Excellent primer on Omicron with links to latest research.  

7. The Economist makes an important point about China's AI ambitions

Despite leading America in the overall number of AI-related publications, China produces fewer peer-reviewed papers that have academic and corporate co-authors or are presented at conferences, both of which are typically held to a higher standard. It ranks below India, and well below America, in the number of skilled AI coders relative to its population. These shortcomings are likely to persist, for three reasons.

First, capital may not be being allocated efficiently... Beijing has created a system for rewarding local officials that favours debt-fuelled spending and seldom punishes wastefulness. Many state AI investments have been “reckless and redundant”... Jeffrey Ding of Stanford University. Zeng Jinghan of Lancaster University has documented the rise of firms that falsely claim to be developing AI in order to suck up subsidies. One analysis by Deloitte, a consultancy, estimated that 99% of self-styled AI startups in 2018 were fake... China’s second problem is its inability to recruit the world’s best AI minds, especially those working on high-level research... Though about a third of the world’s top AI talent is from China, only a tenth actually works there. A shortage of non-Chinese researchers further handicaps China’s capabilities... Even more problematic for the party, its master plan ignored the cutting-edge semiconductors that power AI. Since its publication Chinese companies have found it ever more difficult to get their hands on advanced computer chips. That is because virtually all such microprocessors are either American or made with American equipment. As such, they are subject to restrictions on exports to China put in place by Donald Trump and extended by his successor as president, Joe Biden. It will take years for Chinese companies to catch up with the global cutting-edge, if they can do it at all.

8. Scott Galloway points to the graphic that shows more than half US corporate profits are booked in tax havens, compared to roughly 5% in 1966.

9. Vivek Kaul argues in favour of a K-shaped recovery by pointing to the stagnant affordable housing market (compared to the rising higher income housing credit off-take) and declining two-wheeler market volumes (compared to the rising cars and vans market).

This on housing credit

And this on two wheelers (lowest in eight years)

This compared with a total of 2.15 m units of cars and vans sold in the nine months to December, compared to 1.78 m in 2020 and 2.12 m in 2019. 

10. As the pandemic continues, the OECD estimates that there are a record 30 million unfilled vacancies among its members. This raises questions about the much discussed concern that the pandemic will hasten automation and kill jobs. The Economist has an article which has links on research which points to the opposite direction,

Considering that so many doubts about the “robots kill jobs” narrative have arisen, it is not surprising that a different thesis is emerging. In a recent paper Philippe Aghion, Céline Antonin, Simon Bunel and Xavier Jaravel, economists at a range of French and British institutions, put forward a “new view” of robots, saying that “the direct effect of automation may be to increase employment at the firm level, not to reduce it.” This opinion, heretical as it may sound, does have a solid microeconomic foundation. Automation might help a firm become more profitable and thus expand, leading to a hiring spree. Technology might also allow firms to move into new areas, or to focus on products and services that are more labour-intensive.

A growing body of research backs up the argument. Daisuke Adachi of Yale University and colleagues look at Japanese manufacturing between 1978 and 2017. They find that an increase of one robot unit per 1,000 workers boosts firms’ employment by 2.2%. Another study, by Joonas Tuhkuri of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (mit) and colleagues, looks at Finnish firms and concludes that their adoption of advanced technologies led to increases in hiring. Unpublished work by Michael Webb of Stanford University and Daniel Chandler of the London School of Economics examines machine tools in British industry and finds that automation had “a strong positive association with firm survival, and that greater initial automation was associated with increases in employment”... The methodology used by Mr Adachi and his co-authors is particularly clever. One problem is untangling causality: firms on a hiring spree may also happen to buy robots, rather than the other way round. But the paper shows that firms buy robots when their prices fall. This helps establish a causal chain from cheaper robots, to more automation, to more jobs.

Weekend reading links

1. Italy follows France in imposing revenue-based tax on digital companies, which pay little by way of taxes in countries where they have their users.

The new tax, passed this week by Italy’s parliament, will take effect Jan. 1. Similar to the tax implemented this year in France, Italy’s imposes a 3% levy on revenue on some digital revenue for companies with more than €750 million in global revenue, including least €5.5 million in Italy.

The issue has gained momentum and negotiations are currently on to forge a consensus and arrive at a common tax on technology companies. A EU effort in this regard collapsed on the face of opposition from beneficiary countries like Ireland and Luxembourg.

2. Andy Mukherjee implicitly makes the case for public financing of infrastructure assets, tapping long-term finance and using institutions like NIIF, and recycling of commissioned assets towards private sector to raise capital for more greenfield investments.

3. In a nod to their importance, especially at a time when they are being squeezed by long-term trends, Canada's establishes a Ministry for Middle Class Prosperity! The share of middle-class has been shrinking across OECD countries since the turn of 1990s.

4. The asset markets scale new records,

Stocks and bonds are staging an extraordinary run, on track for their biggest simultaneous gains in more than two decades. Heading into the final two weeks of 2019, the S&P 500 has soared 28.6%, while a bond rally has pushed the yield on the benchmark 10-year Treasury note down three quarters of a percentage point. If the gains continue through the final days of December, it would mark the first time the broad stock index has jumped by at least 20%, while Treasury yields have slipped by at least that much since 1998.

5. This may well be the longest economic expansion in the US history, but it also the weakest on both output growth and job growth. Here is the output growth

... and here the jobs growth.

6. Revealing NYT investigation on mobile phone data and privacy. The short answer is this, howsoever much you anonymise, mobile phone data trace invariably leads to extremely deep invasion of individual's privacy. See this also from Ananth. 

7. As if WeWork's Adam Neumann's $1.6 bn exit package was not enough for blowing up investors money, an FT investigation reveals that there is more to come in case of a floatation.  

8. Talking about non-performing loans, Indian banks are competing with only Greece for leadership.

9. Nice Livemint feature on the Bellary iron ore mining boom of 2006-11 and its bursting following the Supreme Court judgement cancelling mining leases.

10. US productivity growth rate for the decade was just 0.3%!

11. Uniqlo has cracked the problem with handling of soft materials by robots,

There was only one job that robots could not do when Fast Retailing, the owner of Uniqlo, replaced 90 per cent of its workers with robots at its flagship warehouse in Tokyo last year. But now, with the help of a Japanese start-up called Mujin, the world’s third-largest retailer says it has cracked the final barrier to full automation, a priority for Uniqlo as Japan’s ageing population creates labour shortages. The two companies have invented a invented a robot with one arm that can pick up soft T-shirts and place them neatly in boxes to be shipped to customers. While it sounds easy, the ability to lift soft textiles has been a challenge for clumsy robotic arms. Add to this the need to sort through constantly changing seasonal clothes, in shades that are hard to distinguish and wrapped in various forms of packaging, and humans have always come out on top. Even the most aggressive believers in automation, such as Amazon, still depend on human “pickers”.

12. Finally, very interesting twist to Middle Eastern geopolitics. Chastened by the reality that American protection may not be forthcoming, Saudi Arabia has started reaching out to its enemies. Informal contacts have been established with Houthi rebels in Yemen, Qatari regime, and even the Iranians. 

In the months since a missile and drone attack widely seen as the work of Iran left two Saudi oil facilities smoldering, the Saudi crown prince has taken an uncharacteristic turn to diplomacy to cool tensions with his regional enemies... Even though American and Saudi officials agreed that Iran was behind the Sept. 14 attacks on the petroleum processing plants at Abqaiq and Khurais, temporarily halving Saudi Arabia’s oil production, President Trump responded with heated rhetoric but little else. For the Saudis, the tepid response drove home the reality that despite the tens of billions of dollars they have spent on American weapons — more than $170 billion since 1973 — they could no longer count on the United States to come to their aid, at least not with the force they expected... For the United States, the shift toward diplomacy is an awkward paradox. The Trump administration and Congress have been pressing the Saudis to end the war in Yemen, and the administration has pushed them to reconcile with Qatar, largely in vain. Now, the presumed Iranian strikes may have done more to advance those goals than American pressure ever did... Analysts saw the lack of a significant American response to the attacks as a blow to the policy known as the Carter doctrine, which dates to 1980, when President Jimmy Carter vowed to use force to ensure the free flow of oil from the Persian Gulf after the Islamic Revolution in Iran and the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan.