Substack

Friday, November 1, 2019

Behavioural failings of public administrators

I have a co-authored paper with Dr TV Somanathan on behavioural failings of public administrators here on the Prime Minister's Economic Advisory Council website.

It has two parts. The first part covers thirteen commandments to "become better officers", and the second covers twenty insights to "become better policy makers".

Thursday, October 31, 2019

The "Phantom" FDI

The IMF's WEO talks about "phantom investments" or FDI which seeks to benefit from tax avoidance. It writes,
In practice, FDI is defined as cross-border financial investments between firms belonging to the same multinational group, and much of it is phantom in nature—investments that pass through empty corporate shells. These shells, also called special purpose entities, have no real business activities. Rather, they carry out holding activities, conduct intrafirm financing, or manage intangible assets—often to minimize multinationals’ global tax bill. Such financial and tax engineering blurs traditional FDI statistics and makes it difficult to understand genuine economic integration... Globally, phantom investments amount to an astonishing $15 trillion, or the combined annual GDP of economic powerhouses China and Germany... In less than a decade, phantom FDI has climbed from about 30 percent to almost 40 percent of global FDI...


Today, a multinational company can use financial engineering to shift large sums of money across the globe, easily relocate highly profitable intangible assets, or sell digital services from tax havens without having a physical presence. These phenomena can hugely impact traditional macroeconomic statistics—for example, inflating GDP and FDI figures in tax havens. Prominent cases include Irish GDP growth of 26 percent in 2015, following some multinationals’ relocation of intellectual property rights to Ireland, and Luxembourg’s status as one of the world’s largest FDI hosts.

Sample this,
According to official statistics, Luxembourg, a country of 600,000 people, hosts as much foreign direct investment (FDI) as the United States and much more than China. Luxembourg’s $4 trillion in FDI comes out to $6.6 million a person... Interestingly, a few well-known tax havens host the vast majority of the world’s phantom FDI. Luxembourg and the Netherlands host nearly half. And when you add Hong Kong SAR, the British Virgin Islands, Bermuda, Singapore, the Cayman Islands, Switzerland, Ireland, and Mauritius to the list, these 10 economies host more than 85 percent of all phantom investments.
This from the FT.
This should be a matter of concern to countries like India, which aggressively court foreign investments and tweak policies to encourage FDI. Already, only a tiny share of FDI is coming to job creating or export-generating manufacturing activities. What monitoring mechanisms do we have to assess the extent of FDI being driven by profit shifting and other financial arbitrage considerations?

Wednesday, October 30, 2019

More on the balance sheet of privatisation - Chilean edition

From the ProMarket Blog on utility services in Chile, the country which is often hailed as a pioneer in privatisation of infrastructure services,
The median wage is 400,000 CLP (Chilean pesos). That means that half of all workers are making $550 or less every month, and the replacement rate for pensions is only 31 percent. In 2019, the price of electric power increased by 19 percent, despite huge decreases in electric generation costs. Part of the explanation is that the private electric companies have a monopoly position and a law-mandated profit of 10 percent. The same thing happens with water monopoly companies. The biggest of them, Aguas Andinas, had a profit margin of 19 percent in 2013.

Finally, a public transport fare increase was the last straw. On October 6, the cost of a rush-hour subway ride grew from 800CLP to 830 (from $1.10 to $1.14). Those 4 cents were too much, considering that the average worker is spending as much as 30 percent of his income on transportation. Plus, the fares were already high compared with 47 cents for a metro ticket in Buenos Aires or 45 cents in Lima, the other capitals in Chile’s “neighborhood.”
This is illustration of inequality and market concentration is stunning,
The concentration of wealth is also similar to African countries, with the richest 1 percent of the population capturing 30.5 percent of the total income (and the 543 wealthiest households receiving 10.1 percent of that). In 2012, economist Ramon Lopez calculated that the five richest men in Chile, according to Forbes (including President PiƱera), have the same income as the lowest-earning 5 million Chileans.. The beer, tobacco, and domestic air travel markets are each dominated by a single company (with 87 percent, 95 percent, and 74 percent market shares, respectively). And these are just three examples among many; according to the pro-free-market think tank Horizontal, Chileans spend 40 percent of their income in markets without any real competition.

Tuesday, October 29, 2019

SMEs and job creation in India

Ananth and me have an oped in Livemint which summarises our joint work published by Carnegie on  promotion of small, formal firms started by educated entrepreneurs to create productive jobs.

The summary stylised facts,
One, although micro businesses dominate most countries’ economies, India’s economy has an excessive proportion of less productive, informal micro businesses. Two, employment in India is concentrated in these micro businesses, whereas in developed countries, it is concentrated in formal small and medium-sized firms. Three, productive jobs are created by firms that start out as formal. Four, new and young firms create more jobs than older, established firms. Five, growing and efficient firms are founded and run by educated entrepreneurs. Six, with age, Indian firms typically stagnate or decline in employment. Seven, India has a deficit of productive, job-creating entrepreneurs, and an excess of informal entrepreneurs focused on survival.
The full paper is here. An extract here. A review here. 

Monday, October 28, 2019

Higher taxes could encourage racism and anti-semitism???

If there is an annual award for the "Tweet of the Year", then this by Lawrence Summers should make it to the list. In a series of tweets, Summers throws aside all pretensions and declares his allegiance. Sample this,
Forcing the wealthy to spend could boomerang. If the wealth tax had been in place a century ago, we would have had more anti-semitism from Henry Ford and a smaller Ford Foundation today.
And this,
Very few of the problems today involve personal contributions of the wealthy. They instead involve corporate contributions or large groups: e.g., the NRA, the insurance industry, sugar producers...
See the responses on the tweet thread itself. Even an apologetic Paul Krugman cannot take it.

And this,
Wealth inequality is a highly problematic basis for judging a society. Consider a country that put in place super effective social insurance against retirement, disability & health expenses. Middle class people would run their “standby assets” down & wealth inequality would go up
In fact do read the whole tweet thread. It is an exercise in mendacity.

The whole tweet storm is triggered by what appears to have been a very good event at PIIE where Summers had a panel discussion with Emmanuel Saez. 

The larger point that Saez-Zucman make about the need for higher taxes and redistribution to lower inequality is being detracted from by the quibbling over the implementation challenges of a specific set of proposals (never mind the numerous acceptable variations possible, even if the specific set was not feasible). Incidentally, the same Summers was at the forefront of the attack on Thomas Piketty when his book which highlighted the point about widening inequality and how the dynamic of today's capitalism contributes to it. Then the quibble was about how r > g would not always hold or that r was greater largely due to higher real estate prices.

The point about implementation difficulties is one of the main arguments against progressive measures like wealth tax, higher income taxes, breaking up tech companies, and taxing multinationals. This is unsurprising since implementation of most radical changes will ex-ante always appear challenging. But in this case, it is a bit rich coming as it does from ideologues who have played a major role in entrenching the narrative around far more difficult implementation endeavours like valuation of start-ups or executive compensation, both of which have engendered egregious excesses and perverse incentives. 

With nomenklatura like Larry Summers representing them, the Liberals should not be surprised by the rise of the likes of Donald Trump!

Sunday, October 27, 2019

Weekend reading links

1. To give a sense of the demographic challenge facing Japan, sample this from Yubari town in Hokkaido, which recently became the first Japanese municipality to file for bankruptcy,
The town’s population has declined to about 8,000 from roughly 120,000 in the 1960s, according to the local chamber of commerce. The closure of Yubari's coal mines was a blow the community never recovered from; population decline only made matters worse.
2. From Ananth, fascinating analysis of India's income tax revenue trends in Livemint. The major share of income tax comes from salaried income compared to business income,
The total income declared by individuals during AY19 stood at ₹34.1 trillion. Of this ₹20 trillion, or the bulk of the income, was declared by the salaried class. The business income came in next at ₹9.3 trillion. The declared interest income was ₹1.19 trillion, whereas the income from house property stood at ₹37,448 crore... In AY13, individuals paying an income tax of greater than ₹1.5 lakh accounted for nearly 79% of the total tax. This figure fell to 74% in AY15. It has since risen to 79.1% in AY19. A possible explanation for this lies in the higher surcharges that the government has introduced for those in the higher tax brackets over the last few years... The number of people paying an individual income tax of greater than ₹1.5 lakh has increased from 1.38 million in AY13 to 3.49 million in AY19. Nevertheless, as a percentage of the population, this remains a very small proportion. In AY19, 0.26% of the population paid close to four-fifths of the individual income tax, against 0.11% in AY13.

The government appears to be spending more effort and political capital squeezing more tax revenues out from the system, than in trying to expand the envelope itself by enabling growth. The former is easier to do, and the latter difficult. And the former comes with all its perverse incentives. In fact, it worsens the situation without commensurate performance on the latter.

This about housing rental market is very interesting,
According to the data, only around ₹37,400 crore is generated as income from house property in a year (through rents after adjusting for home loan interest, etc.) in the entire country, which shows that much of these transactions are still cash-based and completely outside the tax net... In AY19, around 8.3 million individual returns were filed for house property income. Of these, around 4.67 million declared a negative income from house property. This basically means that they are repaying their home loans. An interest of a maximum of ₹2 lakh paid on a home loan(s) is currently allowed as a deduction from taxable income during a year. Hence, around 3.63 million filers actually made a positive income from house property. If I were to put it a tad simplistically, India has just 3.63 million landlords.
It underscores the challenge about rolling back the cash economy.

3. Also from Ananth, a good set of links to research papers that highlight different signatures of financialisation in the economy. Most of them are covered in great detail in The Rise of Finance.

4. Mint's Macro Tracker shows continuing economic weakness. All the high frequency indicators are in the red.

5. Good summary of India's water problems,
As for water, a near-total reliance on moody monsoons has not made Indians careful users. Around 70% of surface water is thought to be polluted, and pumping from 20m tube wells has dangerously lowered groundwater levels. Indian farmers use more groundwater than America and China combined. They draw as much as 6,000 litres of water to produce a kilo of rice, compared with as little as 600 in China. This is because for 50 years Indian governments have subsidised farming. Water for irrigation is free, and seeds, diesel fuel, electricity and fertiliser are all sold below cost. As a result, India now has a 70m tonne grain mountain and a 15m tonne sugar mountain. It ranks as the world’s biggest exporter of virtual water, shipping out the equivalent of nearly 100bn cubic metres a year in its exports of rice, textiles and other goods. Lack of access to clean water kills an estimated 200,000 Indians a year, and sickens millions more. Once-pleasant rivers such as the Yamuna in Delhi and the Mithi in Mumbai are devoid of oxygen and black with sewage. Bengaluru’s suburban lakes now regularly burst into flames or erupt in towers of toxic foam. Between pollution, overuse and global warming—which appears to be making the monsoons more capricious and slightly less generous—India is fast approaching a water crisis.
6. Even with all its flaws and limitations, the Ease of Doing Business surveys must count as one of the rare policy reform successes of the World Bank.

7. Elizabeth Warren's "fair markets, markets with rules" based manifesto is overall very impressive. Is this the most comprehensive proposal yet on redefining a national economic paradigm? 

8. After becoming America's biggest landlord, private equity giant Blackstone has a new target - warehouses used by e-commerce companies, close to urban areas.
Blackstone owns about 800 million square feet of industrial warehouses, with nearly half of its 443 million square feet in the Americas having been acquired this year.
It raised a record $20 bn real estate fund early this year, and manages $157 bn in investor capital aimed at real estate. 

This about what favours the large funds like Blackstone,
New York firm’s history of double-digit returns and a herd effect, where pension-fund managers and other big investors tend to favor the same brand names with established track records... Even before its latest fund, Blackstone had the record for raising the four largest funds, according to Preqin. Its previous real-estate fund, at $15.8 billion, currently holds the record. Giant firms like Blackstone and Brookfield Property Group typically have an easier time raising money than smaller firms. Investment officers working for pension funds, endowments and other institutional investors prefer firms with marquee names and long track records because they have less explaining to do if things go wrong.
Then there is also the fact that large funds manage to raise debt cheaper than their smaller competitors. 

Saturday, October 26, 2019

The case of Dewan Housing is an opportunity to shine light on corporate India

If you thought that mortgaging the same asset to different lenders was what you only saw with small-time fraudsters and in movies, wait till you read about the latest twist in the case of Dewan Housing Financing Limited (DHFL). 

The company is reeling from a $12 bn pile of debt and is undergoing restructuring efforts, failing which it will have go into bankruptcy, with its ripple-effects across the financial markets.

In this context, Livemint reports about the latest developments in the already unsavoury troubles facing DHFL.
The Bombay High Court is scratching its head and wondering if Dewan securitized — that is, sold to a separate entity — assets that it had pledged to another set of investors to obtain loans. Now, the court wants the beleaguered firm to produce, under oath, a list of assets it repackaged and sold within the last year. This imbroglio has the potential to bring India’s securitization market to a standstill.
As if this was not enough,
A special review of Dewan by KPMG is still in a draft form. But the parts leaked to the media Wednesday raise damaging questions. The auditor says that $2 billion was lent to 25 borrowers with little real business or assets, and that “such entities may be working closely" with Dewan without qualifying as related parties. 
The question that will get asked in the days ahead in a vociferous manner is this. What were the regulators, on both the capital markets and banking sides, doing? 

What will not, unfortunately, get highlighted is the rot within India's corporate sector, where at the slightest opportunity subverting the rules of the game has become passe! 

The blame will get evenly distributed between the unscrupulous promoters and the government. Never mind this is only the latest in the series, the opinion makers will not think it still not appropriate enough to introspect how pervasive such practices are in corporate India.

Update 1 (21.11.2019)

More details, in a balanced apportionment of the blame, on the DHFL story here.

These cases are a matter of great concern about the country's financial market regulation, especially its enforcement, as India becomes increasingly financialised. The practice of mortgaging the same asset to multiple creditors is a case in point. It is even more disturbing since in this case, being collateralised debenture securities on housing loans, it had regulation at both sides - banking (NHB) and securities market (SEBI). The failings of Debenture Trustees, credit rating agencies, auditors etc too are egregious.